Advertisement

Blurring the line between man and beast

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
0

What would you do if you found your child being wantonly cruel to an animal? My guess is that, in many cases, it would depend on what kind of animal. Unless you are a Jain or a Buddhist of strict pedagogic tendency, little Johnny would probably avoid a spanking for squashing a few ants.

But what if the animal were larger and - dare one add - cuter? Then you might step in with a heavy hand. You would at least stop Johnny from carrying on with whatever he was up to. And, especially if Johnny was normally a good boy, you would probably try to find out what caused his actions in the first place.

Note that there is absolutely no basis in morality or science for your choice of action. You show outrage at Johnny poking the dog with the stick - and fair enough. But did you take him to an abattoir before serving that delicious roast of beef last Sunday? Haven't you in fact taken him hunting one time in the United States? And taught him fishing? Weren't you proud of him for killing that snake in Sai Kung last weekend all by himself?

What is at work here is anthropomorphism pure and simple - the feeling that some animals are just so human that mistreating them is not nasty or cruel, but actually criminal. If the absurdity of this isn't immediately obvious, think of your reaction if the dog had been attacking your child. Too bad for any species that isn't cuddly enough.

This is the only way to explain the reaction of a so-called 'animal rights' group to the 'sadistic attack' recently on two kittens in Mongkok. Presumably fearing the outbreak of cat-baiting throughout the city, something calling itself the Animal Welfare Advisory Group has launched a petition to increase massively the legal penalties for cruelty to animals. The group says that existing penalties are 'below international standards', and even our local Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals 'doesn't seem to care'.

Should this kind of creeping confusion between mankind and the beast of the field worry us? After all, Hong Kong people have for long had a high but eminently practical respect for other species. Dogs, cats, rabbits, hamsters and the rest are kept not only by New-Age expatriates but by many normal old or single people to whom they provide the only alternative to the comfort of real human friendship.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2-3x faster
1.1x
220 WPM
Slow
Normal
Fast
1.1x