• Fri
  • Dec 26, 2014
  • Updated: 1:46am

Pataca 'deserves Horse of the Year title'

PUBLISHED : Monday, 01 June, 2009, 12:00am
UPDATED : Monday, 01 June, 2009, 12:00am

John Moore yesterday made an impassioned case for Viva Pataca to be named Hong Kong's Horse of the Year after the famous stayer clawed his way to a third win in the Group One Citi Champions & Chater Cup.

With the HK$2 million bonus he earned for winning two legs of the Triple Crown, Viva Pataca took his stakes earnings to more than HK$71.3 million, making him second only to Vengeance Of Rain (HK$75,410,500) as the most successful horse, money-wise, in Hong Kong racing history.

Although his boom four-year-old Collection (Darren Beadman) failed to cope with the pressure and stamina requirements of this end-of-season 2,400m championship, Moore was thrilled that his veteran stable stalwart had earned top billing.

'I'm very pleased for Viva Pataca, today he's really showed his true form,' Moore said. 'Now, the thing I want for him is to become Horse of the Year as well.

'There's no doubt he deserves it, he's been a great horse, coming back season after season and always competing at the very top level.

'But I've been here over 30 years and I've seen that some people can get very impressed with an overseas Group One win and that blinds them to what they've seen locally. I hope that doesn't happen again. In any case, he's my champion - he's my Horse of the Year.'

Moore was clearly referring to the decision to give Horse of the Year honours to Vengeance Of Rain two years ago, even though Viva Pataca defeated the great New Zealand-bred stayer in both the Audemars Piguet Queen Elizabeth II Cup and the Champions & Chater Cup that year.

A majority of the voting panel decided that Vengeance Of Rain's win in the Sheema Classic in Dubai counted for more than those two clear-cut defeats by his main opponent at home. And even though Viva Pataca won the race billed as the 'decider', the vote ultimately went against him.

In eerily similar circumstances, Sacred Kingdom is about to journey to Royal Ascot and a victory there in the Group One Golden Jubilee Stakes could derail Moore's Horse of the Year hopes once more.

Marwing gained the ride on Viva Pataca when stable jockey Beadman went with the youth and potential of Derby hero Collection, and the South African was very humble in victory.

'It was a great feeling but I do feel very sorry for Darren,' Marwing said. 'I've been in that situation myself and these decisions have to be made but it's not possible to always get them right. I take no credit for the win, full marks to John Moore and all his staff for the great job they've done with Viva Pataca.'

Viva Pataca has now won seven Group Ones, a sequence which began in the Mercedes-Benz Hong Kong Derby of 2005. He has also won the Hong Kong Gold Cup twice, the 2006 QE II and three editions of the Champions & Chater.

That's not a unprecedented, however. Super Win, trained by John's late father George Moore, won the race three times in successive years, 1975-77. Silver Lining also won three Champions & Chaters (1978, 79 and 81) and was prepared by George Moore for the second and third wins.

The supreme champion of the race, however, was the immortal River Verdon, raced by former Jockey Club chairmen Ronald Arculli and Oswald Cheung. River Verdon, trained by David Hill, won the race four times from 1991-94.

Viva Pataca will stay in training next season, with his first target being Vengeance Of Rain's prize money record.

'Viva Pataca will definitely get past Vengeance Of Rain - he's very sound, apart from those well-documented, niggling feet problems, but we've learned how to manage them effectively,' Moore said.

'He will set a very big target for some other champion horse that might come along in the next 10 or 20 years. Whenever that happens, good luck to the horses who want to take that record on.'


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive




SCMP.com Account