-
Advertisement

Potential gains and losses from Arab change

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Philip Bowring

The Arab awakening has implications for East Asia which deserve some thought in regional capitals. The most obvious, as demonstrated by Libya, is that several countries, and Africa generally, are so fundamentally unstable that those like China with money to spend in pursuit of friendship, construction contracts and commodities need to think twice before committing themselves too deeply.

Only slightly less obvious has been the determination and ability of China to rush planes and ships to rescue thousands of stranded nationals. That was beyond the capacity of any other Asian nation with workers at risk. Although this was simply a rescue mission, it sends a message to Asian countries with significant numbers of Chinese people, whether Chinese nationals or ethnic Chinese. However much China may say it respects national sovereignty, blood remains thicker than the watery ink of international rules. Empires often begin not with deliberate attempts of big countries to impose their will on weaker ones but with well-meaning efforts to protect their own citizens' lives and property when threatened by disorder in some foreign land.

Relevant to all of East Asia, not just to China, is another imponderable: what impact will Arab events have on relations between the Arab world, particularly North Africa, and Europe. That matters because Asia has long fulfilled a role which in principle should have been Europe's given its neighbours just across the Mediterranean. Why is it that Vietnam sells many times more shoes and clothes to Europe than Egypt, a country with a similar-sized population, passable physical infrastructure, high unemployment and low wages?

Advertisement

Europe has singularly failed to establish the same sort of relationship with its poorer southern neighbours that Japan, Korea and Taiwan have done with Southeast Asia and China, injecting capital and knowhow into these economies to take advantage of the export opportunities offered by the markets of Europe and the US.

This is not entirely Europe's fault. The Arab world has been mostly unreceptive to foreign investment and trade, lurching from an inefficient mix of Arab nationalism and socialist economics to varying forms of crony capitalism and military- or monarchy-based authoritarianism. The region continues to seethe at the Western implanting of an expansionist Israel on Palestine. But, assuming that the current ferment does lead to real change, what form will it take?

Advertisement

Egypt is pivotal. It is the most populous state and widely recognised as the Arab intellectual and artistic hub. The Egyptians face a dilemma. Socialism was an abject failure, and much of its legacy remains with an excess of government employees and state-owned industries. Yet the alternative, trade and a free-market model, is tarnished by its association with Hosni Mubarak.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x