Debates on spending 'show poor planning'
Kenji Fujimoto was accepted into Kim Jong-il's inner circle during a 13-year stint serving North Korea's first family. The Japanese sushi chef gives Julian Ryall his take on the communist dynasty'...
Hong Kong is seeing more controversy over spending plans because the government is doing a poor job of debating the issues in advance, according to the head of the Legislative Council's finance committee.
Chairwoman Emily Lau Wai-hing said the government should provide detailed documents at an early stage to give lawmakers a chance to react.
'The increasing number of debates over government policies has nothing to do with the looming elections - it is the lack of preparation and consultation work that matter,' said Lau, a vice-chairwoman of the Democratic Party. 'The government should learn a lesson instead of finding excuses.'
Referring to the budget speech in February - after which the government insisted there was no option but to inject HK$6,000 into each Mandatory Provident Fund account - Lau said the government was stubborn about taking advice or listening to critics. 'Before the budget was released, committee members had told the officials a HK$6,000 injection into MPF accounts would not work. But the government insisted,' said Lau. 'What can you do when you have such a stupid administration?'
A week after the budget speech, Financial Secretary John Tsang Chun-wah did a U-turn, scrapped the MPF idea and instead announced that a HK$6,000 payment would be given to every permanent resident aged over 18.
Of the 65 budget plans submitted by the government over the past year, all but one was approved - a proposal to host the 2023 Asian Games.
The plan defeated in January - the only one in the past seven years - was lambasted for its wishy-washy cost projections. Citizens were spooked by an initial cost estimate of HK$44.5 billion, including direct costs of about HK$13.7 billion to HK$14.5 billion, then people were confused when the government slashed it by half to HK$6 billion.