• Mon
  • Jul 14, 2014
  • Updated: 12:40pm
PUBLISHED : Tuesday, 18 September, 2012, 3:36am
UPDATED : Tuesday, 18 September, 2012, 3:37am

Regulators should enhance transparency themselves

The public has been left in the dark after closing auction chaos of 2009 saw HSBC shares plunge


Enoch Yiu is the chief reporter of business pages at the Post. She writes feature stories with a focus on regulatory issues, stock exchanges, the Securities and Futures Commission, accountancy, insurance, pension and other financial industry development issuse. She has a weekly column, White Collar, covering the latest issues in the professional industry and also hosts podcasts and video programs on SCMP.com. She is the author of two books.

The city's regulators have always attempted to set themselves up as corporate role models. The Securities and Futures Commission and Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing both issue quarterly financial reports to increase transparency and release regular updates about their enforcement efforts.

However, there appear to be mysterious gaps in these efforts.

Top of the list is the result of the investigation into the closing auction chaos on the stock exchange in March 9, 2009.

The HKEx suspended the 10-minute closing auctions that day after selling pressure reached a fever pitch. One transaction in the auction's final seconds sent HSBC down to HK$33, a drop of 12.47 per cent during the 10-minute auction period and down 24.14 per cent for the day.

That was the worst decline in almost 20 years. Given HSBC is widely held by Hong Kong investors, the decline was a big upset and raised questions about the exchange's trading infrastructure. The exchange has since then reverted to the old way of calculating the market's price by using the traditional median price from the final five transactions of stocks.

More than three years on, neither the SFC or the stock exchange have mentioned how the investigation is progressing, including how such a big swing in HSBC occurred and who was behind it. Do investors care? They certainly do.

My mother in law, siblings, friends and even my hairdresser have raised the same question over the past few years on why HSBC's price swung so wildly in those few minutes in 2009. Will it happen again? Was there manipulation behind the scenes? Why does the SFC not do anything about it? Is it safe to invest in Hong Kong? How come my HSBC shares went down more than 12 per cent in 10 minutes?

Questions, questions.

Yes, they are all small shareholders and maybe they do not care how the stock exchange determines the closing price of the market. But they are also shareholders and they have the right to know why.

I am often asked by friends and family why I don't follow up on this story. The answer is simple: the SFC and the HKEx have made no comment.

International brokers and institutional investor also want an answer. Institutional investors want the HKEx to reinstate closing auctions but without a report to explain the HSBC debacle it is hard to convince the public to accept a return of the system.


Related topics

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive


This article is now closed to comments

Regulators should enhance transparency themselves ///thank you for your idea but in HKG hope is very less now


SCMP.com Account