• Sat
  • Dec 20, 2014
  • Updated: 9:40am
Lai See
PUBLISHED : Thursday, 28 February, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Thursday, 28 February, 2013, 5:02am

John Tsang's big problem is how to hide Hong Kong's cash


Howard Winn has been with the South China Morning Post for two and half years after previous stints as business editor and deputy editor of The Standard, and business editor of Asia Times. His writing has also been published in the Far Eastern Economic Review, the Wall Street Journal, and the International Herald Tribune. He writes the Lai See column which focuses on the lighter side of business.

Financial Secretary John Tsang Chun-wah was up to his usual tricks with the budget yesterday. His overriding problem is how to hide the oodles of cash that flow into the government coffers. There was the usual "magic" when the budget surplus of HK$3.5 billion forecast last year turned into a surplus of HK$65 billion. For some reason, this appalling inability to get anywhere near the right figure is almost viewed with pride.

In the medium-term forecast that accompanied his 2009 budget, Tsang forecast fiscal reserves for 2012-13 of HK$401.2 billion. But this has ballooned to HK$734 billion, a difference of a mere 83 per cent. So it is with some amusement that we read in yesterday's budget: "We must maintain effective fiscal management …"

Hong Kong's public finances are out of control, and have been for years. This year, Tsang has been reduced to a not so subtle sleight of hand to try to hide some of Hong Kong's largesse. This he needs to do so as to avoid having to explain why he is taking as much as he does from us and why the government is unable to do anything about people living in cages.

So he indulges in a little scare-mongering towards the end of his speech, saying that the government needs to build up reserves to pay for looking after the elderly, HK$300 billion in capital projects and civil service pension obligations, which stand at HK$600 billion. The naive might be alarmed by this since the cash reserves amount to HK$734 billion.

"We may not be able to make ends meet," Tsang observes, although he concedes "we do not need to settle them in a lump sum within a short period …" But he is not comparing like with like. It makes no sense to compare the HK$600 billion pension liability, which comes due over a long period of time with the government's cash reserves. Rather, they should be compared to the accruals accounts. The government's website clearly states that it has reserves of HK$1.38 trillion, almost double its cash reserves.

Hong Kong has more funds than it knows what do with. It is therefore interesting to hear Tsang is setting up a working group to explore ways "to make more comprehensive planning for our public finances to cope with the ageing population and the government's other long-term commitments". If this results in a broad reappraisal of how the government organises its finances, then this is to be welcomed. But it is long overdue.

One thing the group should look at is the government's practice of paying cash for its huge infrastructure projects, which is practically unheard of elsewhere. It should issue bonds so payment for infrastructure that will last for a number of generations will be paid for by the present generation and also future generations that stand to benefit. However, by the time this working group has reported, and there has been a public consultation and the Legislative Council has scrutinised the proposals, it will probably be four to five years. By this time, Tsang and probably Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying will be gone. Meanwhile, Hong Kong will keep piling up surpluses.


Middle-class man

We have often felt that senior government civil servants are somewhat removed from everyday life and possibly out of touch with the people of Hong Kong. This was reconfirmed yesterday towards the end of the financial secretary's post-budget press conference, which had wandered on to the topic of the middle class. At this point Tsang, speaking in Cantonese, said something along the lines, "I think I regard myself as middle class, and I know how Hong Kong's middle class feel." After a moment's pause of disbelief, his observation was greeted by peals of laughter. Good to see the press gets some things right.


Thai PM goes low key

One of our colleagues was surprised recently while walking through Pacific Place when he literally almost bumped into Thai Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra. She was accompanied by a number of officials and appeared to be on her way to the Shangri-La hotel. Our man was struck by the absence of a security presence. He was even more surprised when the party approached the lift and joined the queue behind the other waiting members of the public. They recognised the prime minister and let her through. But her low modus operandi was in stark contrast with visiting dignitaries from you know where.


Have you got any stories that Lai See should know about? E-mail them to howard.winn@scmp.com


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

John Adams
All that surplus money and still NOTHING to be spent on fixing our air pollution problems, starting with the filthy buses and diesel vans
"I think I regard myself as middle class".... what a buffoon
But we all have to breathe the same filthy air , whatever our class.
Christine Loh ! Where were you when this "budget" was drawn up ?
Again shows how the paucity of quality personnel in Government affects the populace. The man is a bumbling oaf on 368k a month plus /plus who cannot predict a surplus from a loss - the Govt even re-employed Edward Yau as the mayor's office manager who did nothing to clear our air during his tenure at ENB, except travel overseas. When I look at my next tax bill and see how Govt is needlessly taxing me on the money I pay to ESF for my children's education it becomes appallingly clear that Govt seems bent on ridding HKG of remaining 'foreigners' here ,no more an Asia world city, just part of China.
“There was the usual "magic" when the budget surplus of HK$3.5 billion forecast last year turned into a surplus of HK$65 billion. For some reason, this appalling inability to get anywhere near the right figure is almost viewed with pride.” Peculiar but true. In normal circumstance, John Tsang would be asked to resign by the Chief Executive for his big error. May be we all should understand what a Financial Secretary role should be. In my view he is the chief accountant for the government in assisting government in money matters: safe keep of what money government has and disperse what money that government promised to spent. And not the least important is to project what money is to be had – correctly, of which a well functioning administration and the city depend upon. So he failed many times. If he is to stay why not set up a study group to investigate cause and remedy for big margin errors in the business of government budget planning. Let the public be informed of the study and may be we will agree too you are still the Financial Secretary for Hong Kong. May be too the study group should define what role that an accountant should not play in the government policy.
PDB, good question. Who sets the budget in term of items? Is the budget vetted by the entire administration and approved by the Chief Executive? Why not deliver the budget in paper or electronic version to legislators and media prior to a question and answer session. We need no speeches.


SCMP.com Account