Giant copper mine offers Mongolia a cash bonanza
Deep in the heart of the Gobi Desert in Mongolia amid a landscape of sand dunes and ice canyons, one of the world’s biggest copper mines is about to come on stream.
Anglo-Australian miner Rio Tinto and Canada’s Turquoise Hill Resources have jointly led construction of the US$6.2 billion Oyu Tolgoi mine which is expected to produce 450,000 tonnes of copper concentrate a year at its peak.
Oyu Tolgoi has estimated that by the time the mine is in full production in 2019, peak earnings could provide up to one-third of government revenue, averaging 800 billion tugriks (about US$575 million) per year over the life of the project.
That holds out the promise of vast revenues for the government that can be spent on infrastructure and education if corruption can be kept in check.
“Most countries that have natural wealth have failed,” President Elbegdorj Tsakhia said in an interview.
“Those that succeed are open countries, meaning they have open policy and democracy,” said the 49-year-old, who studied at Harvard’s Kennedy School of government and was elected in 2009. “I regard my country as an open country.”
The state owns 34 per cent of the joint venture, which is expected to be in operation for at least 50 years. But according to a 2010 study by the IMF, the government will take 55 to 71 per cent of revenues because of royalties and taxes.
The first trucks are envisioned rumbling towards the Chinese border within the first half of next year, where Chinese buyers will take the concentrate to copper smelters for further processing.
The metals are expected to be used in construction materials and consumer electronics, such as copper pipes, iPads and iPhones.
An estimated nine tonnes of gold will also be extracted from the concentrate each year, worth about US$553 million at today’s market rate.
How Mongolia will manage its revenue from the project is a key question for Elbegdorj’s administration, says Oscar Mendoza, managing partner at Mongolia Asset Management, an investment adviser group based in Ulan Bator.
“Will it be Nigeria or Norway? Will it be the Philippines or Qatar?” he said.
Mongolian officials are aware of the so-called “resource curse” that often afflicts developing nations whose enormous natural riches fail to translate into better lives for citizens.
The president cited Norway, Australia and Chile as models for his landlocked nation of 2.7 million people whose average per capita income was US$3,140 last year, according to the World Bank.
To fight possible corruption, the government has put in place what it claims will be a transparent treasury system across its ministries in order to track the flow of money.
“We have been working with them for several years and they have made great progress in many areas. They do have transparency of revenues,” said World Bank resident representative Coralie Gevers.
Mongolia is compliant with the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI), a Norway-based organisation which uses third-party auditors to inspect mining revenue data provided by governments and mining companies.
One of Mongolia’s great hopes for spreading wealth is a so-called Human Development Fund, established to boost social welfare projects. Rio Tinto has already contributed US$803 million to the government in taxes, pre-payments and other fees.
But the mine – open pit initially and underground starting in 2016 – faces objections from some local residents concerned about the environmental impact.
Herders have complained about dust kicked up by trucks, which they say harms livestock. In October, the campaign group OT Watch filed a claim against the mine on behalf of herders seeking compensation.
The mine has also run into political headwinds as vocal backbench legislators demand the government amend its 2009 investment agreement to increase its stake in the project to 50 per cent.
Prime Minister Altankhuyag Norov has not endorsed the calls, but says Mongolia “will revisit and reconsider some aspects of the agreement” because of higher development costs – to the angst of the private developers.
“When a few parliamentarians push government to renege on past deals, it’s not just investors who are hurt, its Mongolians, Mongolian businesses, the entire supply chain,” Rio Tinto spokesman Houston Spencer told a recent conference.
Another pending issue is finalising a power purchase agreement with China which remains incomplete amid ongoing negotiations between Rio Tinto and Beijing, according to the company.
Until it is inked, Oyu Tolgoi cannot switch on key equipment that reduces raw ore to concentrate, a process which makes it economical to export.
The delay could hurt Mongolia’s economy, which has found itself on softer ground in recent months due to falling coal revenue in July and August.
Third-quarter GDP growth was 5.6 per cent, compared with 16.5 per cent in the first quarter, according to the National Statistics Office.
“Any delay in commercial production at the mine could also impact the near term growth outlook,” a World Bank report noted last month.