China Food Scandals
A crisis in confidence in China's food industry emerged after melamine was found in domestically produced baby formula in 2008. The scandal sickened 300,000 babies and resulted in six premature deaths. Other stories of fake eggs, diseased pork, recycled oil, mislabelled meat and more have only led to more calls for industry reform.
Eyes online, milk powder firms count cost of China probes
Stung by bad press, foreign milk powder firms are scouring mainland social media to assess the fallout of scandals in a bid to restore their image
Reuters in Shanghai
Global milk powder firms are scrutinising mainland social media reports up to four times a day to gauge consumer reaction to a high-profile pricing probe and food safety scare that threaten their squeaky-clean image in the US$14.5 billion Chinese market.
The stepped-up monitoring of microblogging site Weibo and online forums reflects the outsized role social media plays on the mainland, where access to information is restricted.
Chatter about food safety scares spreads lightning-fast on Twitter-like Weibo, so companies are learning to keep constant tabs on their online brand reputation.
"We work with a number of clients in this sector and we've been busy, very busy, over the last couple of weeks," said a Chinese-based senior executive at a social media analytics firm.
He asked not to be identified because the firm is working with industry brands including those owned by Fonterra Co-operative Group, Danone and Nestle.
Earlier this month, five international milk powder firms and one Chinese company were fined a record US$110 million after a probe into price fixing in the sector, while a botulism scare at New Zealand dairy giant Fonterra tarnished the wider reputation of imported milk powder.
Reuters analysed the frequency of Weibo posts mentioning the major infant formula brands and found that the number of posts began to increase as early as May, and then peaked at the start of this month, about the time of the Fonterra botulism scare.
The earlier spikes could be explained by the spread of rumours about the milk powder price probe, which was publicly disclosed last month but had been in the works for four months.
The viral nature of social media can also amplify the chatter without necessarily reflecting wider consumer thinking because a single message can be reposted thousands of times.
Nestle, which was named in the pricing probe but escaped a fine, saw the smallest increase in online chatter about its Wyeth infant formula unit, which flattened in July and August.
Mentions of Mead Johnson Nutrition spiked the most, peaking in June, but then returned close to normal this month. The frequency of posts about Dumex and Abbott Laboratories, which makes brands such as Similac, remained elevated until this month, suggesting the companies may have work to do to reassure consumers.
Chatter about Fonterra, which does not have its own-label brand in China, was little affected by the earlier price probes, but saw a sudden steep spike this month at the time of the botulism scare. This month alone, posts that mention Fonterra were five times those in January to July.
Nestle and Danone declined to comment. Mead Johnson, Wyeth and Fonterra did not respond to queries.
Late last year, a Fonterra source said social media on the mainland was going to be a priority. Abbott said it was stepping up social media engagement worldwide.
"Our use of social media is increasing globally as we look to better understand, respond to and connect with our customers around the world," Abbott spokeswoman Kelly Morrison said.
Chinese consumers are highly sensitive to dairy safety after a scandal in 2008 involving melamine-contaminated baby milk powder. At least six babies died and thousands more fell ill.
For the international infant formula brands, the recent scandals hit a particularly sensitive spot: their reputation for safety, which was their primary edge over local rivals.
"The picture that is being painted in China is that their quality isn't that much better than local firms," said Torsten Stocker, a Hong Kong-based partner at consulting firm AT Kearney.
The social data company executive said that infant formula companies had made use of online media to gauge consumer sentiment, track the spread of conversations related to their brands, and work out how to respond to the crisis.
"There was one brand which was holding out and didn't admit involvement until the very end. That made Chinese netizens angry. Other brands did better, responding quickly and getting opinion leaders to support the brand online," he said.
Consultants would now create detailed reports using the data to identify weak spots of brands through the crisis, helping milk powder makers create tailored recovery drives, he said, adding that some firms asked for updates four times a day.
Milk powder makers are also using analysis of online Chinese retailer Taobao to map out demand hotspots in the multitude of lower-tier cities where analysts predict 80 per cent of sector growth.