Microsoft urged to put Mulally, Lawrie on chief executive shortlist
At least three of the top 20 investors in Microsoft want a turnaround expert to succeed Steve Ballmer as chief executive and have urged the technology giant’s board to consider Ford Motor chief executive Alan Mulally and Computer Sciences Corp chief executive Mike Lawrie for the job, several sources familiar with the matter said.
The special committee of the board, which is conducting the search, and its advisers have been meeting with shareholders after Ballmer’s surprise decision late last month to retire within a year, the sources said. It could name a chief executive as soon as the end of this year, the sources said.
In one such meeting, Microsoft said it started with a list of about 40 people, including internal and external candidates, and has been narrowing it down, one of the sources said.
It wasn’t clear whether the Microsoft board had reached out to any of the potential candidates suggested by investors or whether it was even considering them. The names of other candidates in the mix could not be learned.
Microsoft declined comment on Monday. Lawrie and Mulally could not be reached for comment. But last week, Mulally told Reuters that he was “absolutely focused on serving our Ford.”
The sources requested their identity as well as those of the investors be kept anonymous because the discussions were private.
The search for a new chief executive of the world’s largest software maker is one of the most closely watched developments in the technology sector this year.
Microsoft remains highly profitable, but it has struggled to gain traction in the mobile device business against rivals such as Apple and Google.
In July, the company unveiled a deep reorganisation to transform into a “devices and services” leader, but has so far failed to convince investors that its strategy will work. In a sign that shareholders had already lost confidence in Ballmer, Microsoft’s shares rose 7 per cent after news of his planned retirement.
Last week, Microsoft said it would buy Nokia’s phone business and license its patents for 5.44 billion euros (HK$55.7 billion). Shares of the software company fell as much as 6 per cent as investors protested the acquisition of an underperforming and marginalized unit that made a US$3 billion operating loss last year.
The move also brings Stephen Elop, who ran Microsoft’s business software division before jumping ship in 2010, back to the company, positioned as another candidate to succeed Ballmer.
Microsoft Chairman and co-founder Bill Gates, who is still the company’s largest shareholder with a 4.8 per cent stake and is on the four-member special committee, will likely have a veto on the new chief executive choice.
Gates, who has focused his day-to-day activities on philanthropy for the last five years, has not given any indication of what kind of chief executive he favours.
Investors are attracted to Mulally and Lawrie because both have histories of successfully turning around companies, although the Ford chief executive is more widely known thanks to his dramatic reversal of the No. 2 US automaker, the sources said.
Under a succession plan at Ford outlined last November, Mulally, 68, is expected to stay on as chief executive until at least the end of next year. But people with knowledge of the matter said the executive may step down sooner than planned if he finds an appealing new role.
“There is no change from what we announced in November: Alan Mulally plans to continue to serve as Ford’s president and CEO through at least next year,” Ford spokesman Jay Cooney said.
A role as the head of Microsoft would allow him to follow up his seven-year tenure as Ford’s chief executive with another high-profile job. It would also bring him back to Seattle, where he lived during his nearly four decades at Boeing and still has a home.
The other candidate on investors’ radar is Lawrie, a long-time IT executive who engineered a complex fix at UK-based Misys Plc, a financial software company, before joining Computer Sciences last year.
Computer Sciences, which is in the midst of a multiyear turnaround plan under Lawrie, declined to comment.
Lawrie also spent nearly three decades at IBM, where he worked alongside John Thompson, Microsoft’s lead independent director who is heading the special committee, the sources said.
In 2005, Lawrie worked for about a year as a general partner of activist investor ValueAct Capital, a Microsoft shareholder that had pressed for Ballmer’s ouster and has been offered a seat on the company’s board.
Even though Ballmer was more a salesman than a technology specialist, a choice of Mulally, who comes from outside the technology sector, would be a radical departure for the industry.
The major precedent for such a move was IBM’s successful hiring of Louis Gerstner, a manager from the financial industry who turned around the struggling computer company between 1993 and 2002. John Sculley, who went from PepsiCo to lead Apple from 1983 to 1993, was not regarded as being very successful.
Despite its problems, Microsoft is not yet in such a dire predicament as IBM was in the early 1990s. Microsoft reported a profit of US$22 billion last year, despite falling sales of PCs, which are still the key to its main businesses.
Its online and mobile computing efforts do not make money. Its Bing search engine and other online ventures have lost almost US$3 billion in the last two years alone, and last quarter the company took a US$900 million write-down on the value of unsold Surface tablets.
Despite billions of dollars of investment, Windows phones still have less than a 4 per cent global market share, according to the latest figures from research firm IDC.