• Sat
  • Jul 12, 2014
  • Updated: 7:48pm
Jake's View
PUBLISHED : Thursday, 28 November, 2013, 4:17am
UPDATED : Thursday, 28 November, 2013, 4:17am

HKMA's Norman Chan easily spooked by what the US probably won't do

Hong Kong Monetary Authority chief executive Norman Chan Tak-lam warned all local businesses and investors to beware of the risks of an outflow of funds and a sharp rise in interest rates if, as expected, US monetary policy changes next year.

SCMP, November 26

But it is not expected to change next year. The United States has addicted itself so completely to rock-bottom interest rates that any change back to normalcy would threaten vast swathes of the US economy. The talk now is that 2015 is the earliest date.

What we sometimes seem to have in Norman is a professional worrier with no hands-on career experience of financial markets, who can't find much to talk about in front of the cameras unless at the same time he's wringing his hands about financial markets.

Let's look at it from a different angle. First of all, there is the headache that the HKMA itself suffers in following the US lead to keep local rates low.

The present state of affairs reminds me of the old cartoon in which one soldier complains to another during a bombardment that he can't crawl any lower because his buttons are in the way.

By the theory of the peg to the US dollar, at zero interest rates there would be no arbitrage attraction to holding Hong Kong dollars but, as the first chart shows, it doesn't turn out that way when everyone else's rates are also that low.

Our exchange rate to the US dollar is now bumping right against its official HK$7.75 intervention level again although the HKMA has amassed intervention balances of almost HK$1 trillion, the equivalent of 45 per cent of gross domestic product, to keep it from crossing the line. Our self-adjusting peg mechanism has clearly not been adjusting things too well recently.

Should US rates now begin to rise, there is no reason why Hong Kong need follow immediately. A gap between the two might make the self-adjustment mechanism start to work again and take some pressure off the peg.

Meanwhile, the HKMA could also begin to unwind those intervention balances, which would get us yet more time before our rates need go up. It would certainly be a better use for the money than speculation in the London property market, to which Norman has recently resorted.

And then think of the benefits to normal, ordinary bank depositors, which is almost everyone. Total holdings of bank deposits in Hong Kong amount to HK$4.4 trillion. These pay a weighted average interest rate of less than one hundredth of 1 per cent, while consumer price inflation runs at 4 per cent.

Put another way, inflation is robbing Hong Kong savers of the equivalent of about HK$180 billion a year on their deposits. If you have money in HK dollar deposits, wouldn't you like a better return on your money? I certainly would. What's so bad about the idea, Norman?

Then take the property market. The reason we have such atmospheric housing prices at the moment has little to do with housing shortages despite the recent report of a government-appointed study group. The group had its own public housing agenda.

The real reason is that ultra-low interest rates have made home finance ultra-cheap. Interest rates are always the big variable in home prices. Start them on their way up again and home prices will start to come down again. What is so bad about housing prices coming back into the affordability range of normal working people?

Yes, higher interest rates will cause some financial strains. Any big interest rate movements will do so. But there are good things to be said for them as well as bad. Stop wringing your hands, Norman.

Share

More on this story

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive
 
 

 

3

This article is now closed to comments

kctony
What do you expect? He's an AO.
singleline
And the Chinese government is also 'robbing' Chinese savers through artificially low deposit rates.
Without the linked exchange rate system, Hong Kong dollar would possibly have appreciated against the US dollar and other currencies, and Hong Kong's property prices wouldn't have risen as much as they have right now.
Instead of worrying about Hong Kong, Norman Chan should be worrying about China.
Read the article 'Too little Adam Smith for China, too late' published by the Financial Times this morning, and you know what I mean.
For the great number of aficionados of the present Chinese economic reform, to believe in the above article is impossible. Not to believe in it is absurd.
Or so I think.
rpasea
Higher interest rates would also act a stimulus as corporations would need to put their money to work instead of sitting on cash balances that cost them nothing.
.
Low interest rates are not reaching all levels of the economy as a recent notice from Amex reminded me of the 40%+ interest rates they charge.
 
 
 
 
 

Login

SCMP.com Account

or