Why 2016 will be far tougher for policymakers than for investors

PUBLISHED : Sunday, 10 January, 2016, 3:46pm
UPDATED : Monday, 30 May, 2016, 2:19pm

Judging by last week’s trading performance, it has not been the best of starts for global markets and the worry is that it sets the tone for another troubled year. Stock market mayhem and rising investor unease is not good news when the pace of global growth is starting to stumble.

It is hard to credit after seven years of stock market rally that the bubble is about to burst, especially considering the world economy is so flush with liquidity after years of monetary pump-priming by the major central banks.

Ever since the global financial crisis first exploded onto the scene in 2008, world policymakers have waged a fierce policy offensive with quantitative easing, ultra low interest rates and a plethora of super-stimulus to get the world economy back on its feet. Despite all this monetary balm, markets seem to have reached a crossroads.

The special measures have either run out of steam and fresh policy efforts are needed, or else global stock markets have reached their natural peak and are set for a corrective downward spell. It is a combination of both, plus the fact that the global economy is still experiencing painful aftershocks from the global financial crisis.

READ MORE: This is why 2016 will be a dangerous year for investors

Reverberations of deep recession, deflation, high unemployment, austerity cutbacks and severe balance sheet restructuring are still resonating. Years of easy money from the global monetary authorities might have averted deeper disaster in the immediate aftermath of the 2008-9 financial crisis but the world economy is still far from fixed.

Stock market uncertainty is telling the world’s economic leaders some important truths. Stock prices are leading indicators of investors’ future expectations. If share markets are distressed, it means confidence in the future has been undermined. Investors selling assets is the only way to limit anticipated risks ahead.

Central bankers have railed in recent years over ‘irrational exuberance’, excessive investor risk-taking and the dangers of stock market bubbles but the tables have now turned. Global policymakers must acknowledge the market’s rising ‘rational despair’ and do something much more meaningful to correct it.

There have been telltale signs of deepening troubles in the world economy for quite a while. Swathes of economic reports and downbeat confidence surveys have pointed to global growth losing significant forward momentum. Slower growth in China, tensions in the Middle East and the collapse in global commodity prices are all weighing on global optimism right now.

Purchasing managers reports have highlighted the weakening trend of global economic activity for well over a year. Compared with 12 months ago, many major economies have edged below the critical 50 boom-or-bust threshold, suggesting economic growth is heading into a contractionary phase.

Critically, the US manufacturing PMI has seen a sharp reversal in fortunes over the last year, with surveys suggesting the pace of US economic demand is slowing down quite rapidly. This is in sharp contrast with the picture portrayed by the fast pace of US employment expansion in last week’s 292,000 non-farm payrolls surge for December.

Right now, the US Federal Reserve seems solely focused on stronger employment trends and ignoring the unsettling PMI message. The data not only alludes to weaker economic activity ahead, but also pin-points a continuing deflation threat with price expectations running at their lowest level for nearly 7 years.

The worrying aspect is the Fed remains so dead set on pushing rates higher. The Fed’s whispering campaign suggests a number of key officials would even prefer to see 4 to 5 more rate rises this year. If the Fed is so determined to press ahead with tightening, the bigger risk is at what stage the central bank starts the ‘great unwind’ of its 4-1/2 trillion dollar hoard of QE purchases. That would spark a major blowout in US bond yields.

It is the sting in the tail for investors. With the world’s largest economy so committed to policy tightening, it means borrowing rates for the indebted nations around the world are going up. This is bad news for global economic confidence and growth.

There are few places left for investors to run and hide. Traditional safe-haven bond markets, like German government bonds, are heavily oversubscribed and carrying negative yields across much of the yield curve. The investment challenge this year will be finding secure boltholes, with negligible risk and positive expected return.

2016 has the makings of a really tough year for investors. But it will be even more demanding for global policymakers seeking solutions.