Apple shares hold flat after earnings

PUBLISHED : Thursday, 25 April, 2013, 9:38am
UPDATED : Thursday, 25 April, 2013, 9:45am

Apple shares swung sharply from red to black and back again after the company’s shock earnings report, but its huge boost to its capital return program helped the stock end nearly flat.

Shares in the iPad and iPhone maker plunged more than US$13 at the opening after Apple reported a fall in quarterly profits for the first time in nearly a decade after the markets closed on Tuesday.

But the other news from the earnings announcement -- that Apple would more than double the money put to dividends and share buybacks to US$100 billion -- took hold and brought the shares back to the break-even level.

At the close on Wednesday, shares were down 67 cents to US$405.46, clinging for a second day above US$400.

Sentiment was clearly mixed after the company’s fiscal second quarter report late Tuesday (covering to March 31), which showed Apple less able to squeeze profits from its big products than before in the face of tough competition in the smartphone and tablet markets.

The company posted a profit of $9.5 billion (HK$73.76 billion) on revenue of US$43.6 billion (HK$338.52 billion in the first three months of this year, compared to US$11.6 billion (HK$90.06 billion) on US$39.2 billion (HK$304.36 billion) in revenues a year earlier.

Revenue growth of 11.3 per cent “would be good for most companies, but Apple isn’t most companies,” said Patrick O’Hare at

“That marks a major deceleration from the 59 per cent year-over-year growth registered in the same period a year ago.

Product sales numbers grew -- iPhones sold in the quarter rose to 37.4 million from 35.1 million a year earlier, and iPads sold surged to 19.5 million from 11.8 million.

But margins were clearly shrinking: the gross margin fell to 37.5 per cent from 47.5 per cent.

The slowdown, after a performance over recent years that regularly stunned the markets and sent Apple shares soaring to US$705 in September, was expected by analysts, and in fact profits came in better than forecast.

But it also came with a warning from chief executive Tim Cook that the next quarter would not come in as well as expected by analysts.

“Although we’ve achieved incredible results, we acknowledge our growth rate has slowed,” Cook said.

“We will continue to focus on the long term and we remain very optimistic about our future.”

What buoyed shares as much was the plan to return more of the company’s US$145 billion (HKJ$1.13 trillion) war chest to shareholders, and several analysts keeping a target for the company’s price well above where it traded Wednesday.

Apple said it would add US$55 billion (HK$427.03 billion) to the previous US$45 billion (HK$349.39 billion) in its capital return program, including a 15 per cent dividend increase.

“We will fund the capital return program from operations and borrowing,” said Peter Oppenheimer, Apple’s chief financial officer.

Silicon Valley analyst Rob Enderle said Apple was “selling off Apple’s future to prop up Apple’s stock price in the short term.”

A number of analysts cut their price targets for the company after the results, but still rated it a buy. Deutsche Bank lowered its target to US$480; UBS to US$500; Canaccord Genuity to US$560 and BMO Capital a less enthusiastic US$435.