• Mon
  • Dec 22, 2014
  • Updated: 11:44am
CommentInsight & Opinion

China must see past its own hype of an America in decline

Zha Daojiong says Chinese policymakers and analysts should not believe their own jingoistic rhetoric about a US in decline. Even if it's true, a weak America isn't good news for China

PUBLISHED : Wednesday, 18 June, 2014, 5:47pm
UPDATED : Thursday, 19 June, 2014, 3:04am

Talk of the US being on the decline is back in vogue. This time, China features more prominently - if not solely - in the follow-up question: which country is going to benefit? My answer is different: it's certainly not China who will benefit.

Arguably, the first round of sentiment claiming that the United States was in decline emerged in the wake of the Arab oil embargo on America and its allies in 1973. A little more than a decade later, Japan's rise to be No 1 in economic affairs helped bring back the questions about America's relative place in the world. However, in both instances, America managed to have the last laugh.

How does China feature in the current mood in the US about America's place in the world? It is not as if China has behaved as Opec did in October 1973. Quite the opposite, in fact; Chinese economic growth is helping to power the global economic recovery.

Nor is the Chinese presence in American society even close to that of the Japanese in the mid-1980s. To many American geostrategic thinkers, the crux of the issue is that China, unlike Japan back then, has failed to meet US expectations of evolving to become a "like-minded" country, in either domestic or foreign policy.

To make matters worse, China is simultaneously at odds not just with the US but most of its Asia-Pacific allies on maritime territorial and a host of other diplomatic and geostrategic issues in the Middle East and Africa. To be sure, China is decades away from competing on an equal footing with the US on military terms, if indeed that is ever attainable. But it does seem capable of making the US look hollow when Washington offers to defend its Asian allies against a not-so-thinly-veiled threat.

China abounds with jingoistic rhetoric about a declining US, particularly in the wake of the collapse of a number of large banks in 2008. But it would be a serious error, not to mention profoundly risky, for China to promote domestic and foreign policy choices based on that shallow premise. One should remember that, in the past half century, the US has managed to rejuvenate its economy, regain social cohesion and maintain its influence in setting standards in global economic and military affairs. Indeed, the very fact that rhetoric about the US in decline has resurfaced in American society is, in itself, a sign of American strength, starting with brutal self-reflection.

One risk for China is that if it does indeed conclude that the US is on a path of decline, it may then think the time has come to design domestic political and economic policies in a purportedly unique Chinese way. China's top leadership is correct to remind the country that reform is a never-ending process. As to how to reform, China can learn from the US. If anything, what comes across as American pressure or seemingly excessive demands ought not to be dismissed as unwanted intrusion.

Chinese analysts can better serve their country by publicly admitting that policy ideas from the US, not just finance or export opportunities, have contributed positively to China's prosperity.

Another risk, more so for the Chinese thinkers considering the country's foreign policy choices, is to continue triangulating the geostrategic situations in China's neighbourhood and beyond, with the US seen as that ever-present third party. It is self-defeating to believe that now the US is on the decline, China can afford to be less mindful of possible repercussions in policy choices towards another country.

For China, the US, and the other party, it is useful to bear in mind the saying that it takes three legs to keep a stool stable. In other words, to avoid a downward spiral in regional security dynamics, it is essential to ditch the thinking that one party's loss means an automatic gain for the other two. Each pair of countries should learn to work out their differences by themselves.

Whether the US is in decline is really more a matter of perception than fact.

At the end of the day, what happens inside the US - and in China for that matter - will dictate whether it thrives or falters, more than any outside influence. What really matters is that both China and the US learn to accept some level of unpredictability about the future and proceed to interact with each other.

Zha Daojiong is a professor of international political economy at the School of International Studies, Peking University


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

By most measures like the hundreds of thousands of homeless, having the largest number of felons running into millions in jail, the gutting of the middle class, a failed foreign policy where the US is being opposed and losing friends, the never ending War on Muslims and the aftermath, the military pivot to Asia etc., the USA is definitely in decline although it is still the most powerful country.
A clever strategy for China to follow is not to believe its own propaganda.
In Beijing, when you get out of several subway stations, take a look at the newspapers/magazines kiosk. There on the vertical display, you can see at least 10 different military magazines: one with navy ships, one with thanks, one with jet fighters, one with military personnel, one with missile launchig system. In which other country can we see such a public display of military readings! I can only think of an authoritarian regime, with nationalistic overblown sentiment, heading for confrontation.
Every year hundreds of thousands of Chinese emigrate to the West with the actual number including pending applications difficult to determine, as the number is huge. Guess which country is their #1choice? That's right, it's the US by far. How many people from the West are emigrating to China? Heck, you can almost count them on the fingers of one hand. Every year China loses more and more friends with the aggressive actions taken by her and even with their so-called close allies, North Korea, Russia, Cuba, Vietnam?.....there is mistrust between them going back generations. It's understandable that countries around China will coordinate their efforts to contain China's ambitions for world domination in all aspects. The only way China has made the few friends she has, is by pumping money into select countries and developing natural resources for mainly its own use.
Once the real estate bubble bursts as predicted by experts both inside and outside the country, and as more and more businesses leave for Cambodia, Indonesia, Vietnam, Philippines, etc., it's anybodies guess just how badly the country will fare, but it won't be pretty. Sort of a "Rags to Riches to Rags" story.
The comments on Chinese emigration to the US are noteworthy. Here in NYC, we see all kinds of immigrants from China. The poor continue to pay smugglers to enter the country to work as dishwashers in Chinatown, while an increasing number of rich Chinese are buying multi million USD apartments in Manhattan and sending their kids to Ivy League universities. And guess which country tops the list of applicants for our immigrant investor program? China. The poor will always flee for economic reasons. But. The fact that the rich are leaving says something profound. If things are so good in China, why are so many people leaving?
Unless you could overcome the language barrier, you are not welcomed to migrate to China.
The best way to determine whether a nation is set to become the world's No. 1 is by examining how many people actually intend to migrate there. Historically, the US has and still remains as the magnet of the world. But how many people in the world want to migrate to China?
Ask our own Chinese cousins. Who cares if the US economy is in decline?
US GDP per capita top 10
China GDP per capita 83-93th
I haven't met a colleague in China who wouldn't want to move to western countries. A better life for the family always comes first.
Good essay. It's always a mistake to bet against the U.S. The U.S. has the weakest President since Jimmy Carter 1976-1980. American people don't like the current state so expect changes coming. As for China, it doesn't look like China's ascent will continue on it's present path. China, Taiwan and Japan rose to advanced prosperity with increased international engagement and capitalism, both of which China is pulling back from.
So many Chinese are moving to the US that US will just become another state of China.



SCMP.com Account