• Sat
  • Dec 20, 2014
  • Updated: 9:44am
Culture Club
PUBLISHED : Friday, 02 May, 2014, 6:35pm
UPDATED : Friday, 02 May, 2014, 7:17pm

Screen icon-turned rock star Maggie Cheung ‘wows’ audience in China


Vivienne has been a cultural journalist and critic for over a decade and was named one of the world’s best young journalists and critics while representing Hong Kong at the 2004 inaugural Berlinale Talent Press at the Berlin International Film Festival. She has written extensively on culture and entertainment for publications locally and abroad and has covered major international events from film festivals to art fairs. Vivienne also covers Hong Kong and global cultural policy development and publishes a blog, Culture Shock, at www.viviennechow.com. She is the culture beat senior reporter at the South China Morning Post and can be followed on Twitter @VivienneChow.

Everyone has a dream. So does Maggie Cheung Man-yuk, one of the greatest actresses from Hong Kong and probably the Chinese-speaking world. On May Day in Shanghai, the screen icon took the stage of Strawberry Festival to realise her dream to become the next rock star and she “wowed” the audience – but not exactly in the way she intended.

Strawberry Festival is a three-day music extravaganza brought by Modern Sky, a music label based in Beijing that has discovered some of the best indie voices from China, including one of my favourites Hopscotch. When Modern Sky recently announced that the award-winning actress will be featured in the line-up alongside international acts like Justice at Strawberry Festival in Shanghai, it was quite a shock.

Cheung has been leading a semi-retired life after Clean (2004) directed by her ex-husband Olivier Assayas. The drama was a mediocre one but Cheung’s performance as a junkie and single mother struggling to rebuild her life and winning her son back won her the prestigious best actress award at Cannes Film Festival (she did sing a song at the end of the film).

Her last so-called screen appearance was 2010’s Ten Thousand Waves, which is in fact a nine-channel video installation by London-based artist Isaac Julien. Cheung is featured as the goddess of Mazu in the video installation that juxtaposes contemporary Chinese cultures against ancient myths. An exhibition of the work at the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in New York just closed in mid-February.

Thus, Cheung’s attempt to reinvent herself as a rock star and performing live had quite a draw. Modern Sky said Cheung has formed a five-piece rock outfit and has been rehearsing with the band for four to five hours each session. There created a lot of expectation.

But then, great anticipation leads to greater disappointment. According to mainland reports, thousands congregated in front of the stage and filled up the area. Cheung took the stage at about 7.30pm and performed songs including Teresa Teng’s classic Tian Mi Mi (As Sweet as Honey), a cover of Rihanna’s Stay and her own song Visionary Heart. But fans were disappointed by Cheng’s low-pitched voice and flat singing, criticising Cheung for singing out of tune. Some Chinese media reported that many walked off in the middle of the gig.

I didn’t get to see her live debut. But thanks to the internet, I got to catch some video clips of her singing performances. Cheung is known for her low-pitch voice even in movies but it has always been her signature and is perhaps one of the many factors that made her screen presence so mesmerising.

And her singing debut? She’s certainly far from being a professional but I do envy her courage to have a new beginning from scratch after accomplishing so much (provided that she has the time and money). But people are very critical of her singing. For some reason, people like to beat down on others, especially those who are already successful. Would people have given a different verdict if it wasn’t Maggie Cheung but some anonymous newcomer singing?

What’s your verdict?


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

She is pretty bad. Her singing is totally flat and she has no force behind it. Everyone dreams of being a singer, but most people know not to take it out of the KTV.
its alright.... kinda how i sing at karaoke in ceo maybe?
Where are her friends and minders to tell her she isn't Edith Piaf, and so to stick to singing in her bath, and out of sight. Whatever is required for a show performance, she hasn't got it.
It's very disappointing to see that the most talented actress Maggie has dropped and compromised her professional artist standard to feed her self-centered ego and desire to destroy the whole Music Festival, i wonder how she could sleep well at night facing many crazy fans and music promoters who have paid her fortune to invite her performing. I wish she could learnt some tips from too-soon-departed Leslie Cheung who is so talented in both acting and singing, in fact he's such a role model of perfectionism in his art, without it, it's a shame that one's carrying a so called "renowned international artist" .. as a sincere fan to MC's acting craft, I wish her continue her great artwork than throwing some rubbish in the name of her hard-built artist image, cause Maggie, You Are Kim Kadarshain!! Respect your Art, respect your Artist Image!!


SCMP.com Account