• Thu
  • Dec 18, 2014
  • Updated: 4:32pm

Aircraft carrier Liaoning

China's first aircraft carrier went into commission on September 26, 2012 and was named "Liaoning" after the northeastern province. The 300-metre ship, refurbished and upgraded from the unfinished Soviet carreir Varyag, which China bought from Ukraine in 1998, is believed to be years away from active service. 

CommentInsight & Opinion

China's aircraft carrier accomplishes its mission - bolster Chinese pride

Trefor Moss says China's first aircraft carrier may not be combat-ready, should regional rivalries escalate, but as a symbol of national pride it has already won the battle on the home front

PUBLISHED : Saturday, 29 September, 2012, 12:00am
UPDATED : Saturday, 29 September, 2012, 2:28am

There's a war on (you must have noticed). It is a war on several fronts: China is fighting Japan to the east, the Philippines and Vietnam to the south, and the United States wherever you choose to look. And it's escalating.

This week, China unveiled the ultimate weapon in this war: the aircraft carrier Liaoning. It is exactly the right weapon for the kind of war that China is fighting - which is a war of words, of feelings, of gestures, and of symbols.

As China and its neighbours squabble over obscure territories such as the Diaoyu and Spratly islands, the Liaoning - which officially entered navy service on Tuesday - fired its opening salvo in this war of sentiment and self-image. Its first mission was not to destroy enemy targets, but to create an impression. It accomplished that mission beautifully, without even raising anchor.

The ship's commissioning was like a graduation ceremony, only it was the Chinese nation as a whole that was graduating, attaining membership of the world's most exclusive military club. There is no symbol of military power more potent than an aircraft carrier, and now China has one, for the first time. Let the trumpets of nationalism sound.

But there's a big drawback. A phoney war is the only sort that the Liaoning is any good for. In a real shooting war, it would be mincemeat.

China's leaders are, of course, well aware of this. When they bought the carrier, a rusty relic of the Soviet war machine, from Ukraine in the 1990s, they initially planned, or so they said, to turn the ship into a floating casino. Instead, they opted for a different sort of gamble, and set about turning the ship once more into a functioning military vessel.

But it was always going to be a ship with severe limitations. The now-renamed Liaoning is like an iPhone without any apps: it's nothing more than a dumb platform. It needs aircraft, and pilots who can fly them (it currently has neither). It needs a dedicated flotilla of support ships that can defend it (same story). It needs crewmen who understand the complexities of carrier operations (not something you can pilfer from the Pentagon mainframe). All these essential working parts will take a long time to develop and integrate into a fully operational machine.

For now, the Liaoning is a lot like the old banger you buy your teenager when he's learning to drive. China's sailors will use it to master all the basic manoeuvres; if they put a few scratches on it and grind a few gears, no one will mind. Several years from now, when they have passed their driving test, Beijing will give them something newer and shinier - indeed, some analysts think that work has already started on the construction of China's first indigenous aircraft carriers.

This is all in the future. For China's neighbours, the arrival of the Liaoning is hardly anything to start panicking about. All the Chinese navy did this week was to play the opening gambit in a very long game: 20 years from now, it still may not have an aircraft carrier that it would feel confident about sending into battle. After all, the last thing you want is for your flag-bearer, your symbol of national power, to be sunk by a lesser opponent - especially, dare I say it, in an avoidable skirmish over some tiny, uninhabited islands.

However, the Liaoning puts China's rivals on notice. Confronting China is only going to get tougher, and the possible repercussions of provoking Beijing more and more serious. Faced with the diminishing returns of resistance to Chinese pressure, it may even occur to some rivals just to let China have those obscure little islands, and be done with it.

But let's not forget that in China's war of pride and possession, the home front is far more important than the scattered territories that are causing all the fuss. The Liaoning may not as yet be carrying any aeroplanes, but it certainly carries the ambitions of a huge cross-section of Chinese society - those people who feel sore about China's previous loss of status, and who now feel energised by its reclamation of power.

This is a ship that makes them feel good about themselves, and about China's place in the world. Best of all, from Beijing's perspective, it makes them feel reassured about the Communist Party's stewardship of the nation. Everyone knows that these are unsettled times in the closed caucus of Chinese government. Times could get a lot tougher, too, as the economy undergoes a wrenching structural shift to a lower-growth model that could fuel resentment among millions of have-nots. Feel-good tokens like the Liaoning are therefore more critical than ever.

In the end, that is the Liaoning's primary objective: not to make other countries feel scared; but to make Chinese people feel proud.

Trefor Moss is an independent journalist based in Hong Kong and former Asia-Pacific editor for Jane's Defence Weekly. Follow him on Twitter @Trefor1


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

The following are excerpts from my post today. You can find the full text at:
Let’s remember that China began to refit the carrier about 8 years ago when there was no tension in East and South China Seas so that there is no need to make Chinese people feel proud for the carrier. Certainly, China made its long-term plan for the development of its aircraft fleet long ago. It has nothing to do with making Chinese people proud.
What was China’s plan then?
It is obvious to those who understand Chinese history and Chinese people’s mindset that a nation who was bullied for more than a century by foreign powers wants to be strong enough to prevent any future bully.
China knows well that its weapons are inferior now; therefore, its leaders, political scientists, well-known journalists, academics, etc. have the consensus that China needs two decades of peace. They believe that by 2030, its economy will be much bigger and its weapons will be superior to put an end to its century-long history of being bullied by other countries.
Can such a second-rate aircraft carrier make Chinese people proud? I don’t think Chinese people are so cheap.
What I have learnt from Chinese military experts, TV talking shows and common people’s talks is that China needs 6 to 8 advanced aircraft carriers, mostly nuclear ones.
…one thing they can look forward to is a gift from Vietnam who has no carriers. its called the SS-N-22 Sunburn……


SCMP.com Account