• Thu
  • Apr 24, 2014
  • Updated: 12:14am

Lamma ferry disaster

A boat owned by Hongkong Electric carrying more than 100 staff workers and their family members collided with a ferry in waters off Lamma Island at about 8.20pm on October 1, 2012. More than 100 passengers on the boat fell into the water. Thirty-nine people were confirmed dead after the accident. This is the deadliest boat accident in Hong Kong in 40 years.

 

CommentInsight & Opinion

Surrounded by the sea, Hongkongers must learn to swim

PUBLISHED : Saturday, 13 October, 2012, 12:00am
UPDATED : Saturday, 13 October, 2012, 4:13am

Hong Kong is surrounded by sea and blessed with fine beaches, yet few citizens are good swimmers. That was highlighted tragically on National Day with the Lamma boat collision and the drowning of two teenage boys at Shek O. If swimming had been of greater priority at school, private lessons more affordable and the number of public pools greater, there is a chance that lives would have been saved. First, though, society needs the right mindset.

School is the best place to teach the fundamentals of swimming. But space constraints and cost mean that only a handful of elite schools have such a luxury. Teachers have to turn to public district pools which are not only few and far between, but heavily booked. Many parents also think of education as being about classroom study, not the outdoors.

The result is that a typical student learns only the bare fundamentals of swimming. Private lessons are often seen as too costly. The government recognises the need to learn swimming, but its subsidised lessons are so in demand that those applying get chosen by luck. They need to win a lottery for a class space and enter a ballot to get on the waiting list.

Being surrounded by sea and catching a glimpse of it regularly does not make us experts in marine conditions. Six people have now drowned off beaches since 2010 and hundreds have been rescued and involved in accidents. If safety measures are ignored, the risks are heightened. The two boys who died broke a cardinal rule of beach-going - they decided to go for a dip early in the morning, before lifeguards arrived and safety flags indicating the conditions had been hoisted.

For many, there is no better place than a beach or boat trip to relax. Authorities have a duty to ensure that schools are able to teach swimming to a reasonable standard. For that, there has to be more public pools and affordable lessons. But even with these basics, swimmers have to use common sense by paying attention to notices and warnings and go in the water only when lifeguards are on duty.

Share

2

This article is now closed to comments

nosidam
I agree totally with the writer of the article. As a resident of Lamma with clean beaches nearby I was always surprised that there are almost no swim classes given on weekend or summer mornings. My North American upbringing made swimming a necessary skill that can benefit one for both survival, exercise, health, and enjoyment. While parents in Hong Kong who have funds will not hesitate to spend them on academic tutoring few will spend them on supplemental swim lessons. Others without funds are at the mercy of the subsidized system as the writer mentions. It is up to the government or corporate sponsors to bring all students to a basic standard of competence, similar to ones mandated for academic performance.
pauluszimmerman
Swimming lessons should be compulsory for every school kid. It is a basic skill everyone requires for personal safety, for leisure, recreation and sports. Especially since HK has 260 islands and 800 km of coastline.

Login

SCMP.com Account

or