Man of the moment Riccardo Tisci's dark, sensual designs for Givenchy come straight from the heart, writes Jing Zhang.
- Thu
- May 23, 2013
- Updated: 10:30am
Trending topics
Hong Kong must manage mainland visitor flood before a bust-up occurs
Michael Chugani says we must find more sensible ways to cope with the flood of mainland visitors before a bust-up does us real harm
Another fire has been put out. We have to pay a heavy price every time we do that. This time, the price was particularly high. We had to become the only society worldwide that restricts outbound travellers to two tins of baby milk powder. It's almost comical. We're taking about milk powder, for goodness' sake, not gold bars or cash-stuffed suitcases.
This self-inflicted stab into our free market principle was not the only price we paid. Train passengers now face even tighter restrictions on the size and weight of what they take on board. We had to pacify local mothers furious with parallel goods traders for draining our supply of baby milk powder to sell on the mainland for huge profits.
Before this, we had to put out the fire of rich mainlanders paying big bucks to buy property here, making homes unaffordable for locals. Then, too, we had to interfere with the free market with tough measures to cool property prices.
And don't forget the fury of local mothers who had to compete for hospital beds with mainland pregnant women giving birth here so their babies could qualify for Hong Kong residency. Hundreds of thousands of such babies were born before Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying blocked mainland women from giving birth here.
But thousands of Hong Kong-born mainland children have now reached school age and are competing with local kids for scarce places at border town schools. Local parents demand priority for their children. Each of the fires we have had further inflamed anti-mainland sentiments.
I have long banged my head against the wall warning that we need to move beyond political sensitivities and admit we have a ticking time bomb. We've had tensions with mainlanders over hospital beds, high property prices, parallel goods traders, baby milk powder, inflation and school places. What next? Crowded roads, MTR seats, or more shopping areas being "colonised" by them? It doesn't sound all that far-fetched if we remember the flare-ups over such minor things as mainlanders eating in MTR trains and restaurants changing their menus to simplified Chinese.
Policymakers have so far succumbed to political correctness by pretending that sticking band-aids on every flare-up will defuse the bomb. But it just delays the explosion. If estimates are correct, mainland visitors to Hong Kong will rise from the current 35 million to 50 million a year by 2015, or about four million a month. Is there a band-aid big enough to hide the tensions this will most likely spark?
Everything has a breaking point. Do we kid ourselves that we'll never reach that point, or dare we ask the tough questions that need to be asked? How many more mainland tourists can we handle or actually need? Should we slow the flow until we can handle more? Who benefits from the influx aside from retailers? Is it worth trading our way of life - and quality of life - to boost tourist dollars? Does integration simply mean being swamped by mainland visitors? Surely, these are sensible, rather than xenophobic, questions?
Michael Chugani is a columnist and TV show host. mickchug@gmail.com
Share
- Google Plus One
-
19Comments
Related topics
After reading this article, people also read
10:36pm
7:19pm
1:19pm
10:38pm
Retailers? Though sales may have gone up for some retailers, who is benefiting. The workers are busier than ever dealing with some of the rudest people you can imagine. But the salaries sure haven't kept up with the cost of living. $28-$30 per hour doesn't go very far these days. Then the actual retailers are paying more for less when it comes to retail space.
Then there is the rest of us who pay more for food, housing, transportation and everything else. So who have these visitors benefited? The 1% and a few government officials who have won some brownie points with the communists.
It is time to reset the quota to family visitors and groups and about 5000 individual travelers a day. Hong Kong people want an affordable place for Hong Kong people and we don't want to be the corrupt official money laundering machine for China.
8:18pm
these are NOT TOURISTS
99% are financial vultures
from property to smuggling goods accross the border
this is a tiny terrritory under siege by over a billion greedy nose pickers from the north
1:53pm
12:41am
Now read the opinions of the other commentators - hateful whiners - here. Their uniform deranged symptom is quite different from ours. It's a shrill nonstop scream, "Them against us, Them against us." They have come into an emergency room abusing doctors and nurses, demanding exorcism of this phantom Them but not medical treatment. Maybe only Cardinal Zen is up to this task.
Indeed, they need to take a detour to Marquis de Sade Hospital, where they would be straitjacketed and recharged daily with a brainwashing diet to energize their self-hate chants. Staff there is well trained by the University of Yellow Journalism, Church of Democratic Catholicism and Conscience of Hong Kong Institute.
To be sure, their disease is incurable. But the treatment prescribed here will make them feel better.
PS This note is inspired by the Chinese character for rabid, but not 狂人日記.
11:56am
10:47am
It is ironic that it is only because China is considered to be Communist country that our freedom loving Hong Kongers could consider proposing greater restrictions on movement. Could you honestly imagine the outcry should the US restrict the number of visitors to New York or if London was to say only a certain number of people from the North of England were to be allowed to visit at one time? How's about Beijing set up a quota for the number of Hong Kong people allowed to visit the mainland at any one time?
Our city and its leaders, as did numerous other cities throughout the world, promoted internal tourism as a means of boosting a flagging economy. The fault for this chaos lies not with visitors from other parts of China, but from successive HK Governments who have just uttered the invitation but not provided the necessary tourist infrastructure.
My hope for the New Year of the Snake is that those, such as aplucky1, who constantly display xenophobia towards other Chinese would leave or stay silent.
1:08am
Right this moment the Obama administration is looking for some legal justification to assassinate its own citizens who are alleged terrorists with drones and other means. What about the massive killings -- hundreds of thousands, destruction of power plants, hospitals based on alleged, but nonexistent, weapons of mass destruction by the two most democratic countries, the US and the UK? Do I hear any outcry?
What if Beijing were doing the same with Hong Kong subversives? Aren't we making mountains out of molehills with the territorial disputes in Yellow Sea and South China Sea?
Let us put Hong Kong problems in the proper perspective.
4:49am
Sorry about that, you're dead wrong. CY is doing the right thing. In the Land of Braindead Democracy -- or for any country aspiring to become one, you must pander to the lowest common denominator, i.e., the hate-mainland passion.
"If estimates are correct, mainland visitors to Hong Kong will rise from the current 35 million to 50 million a year by 2015, or about four million a month."
Now you begin to sound like Chicken Little and the Chinese 杞人憂天. The sky maybe overcast and we can see the thick air that we are breathing, but it is not falling.
As mainlanders become richer, they will in all likelihood visit places like Paris and Milano, where people have better attitudes and welcome their renminbi. They may even sell their flats purchased here just a short while ago. I just hope that cultural icons like Li Yunde and Lang Lang will still stick around.
If it all pans out as expected, that is, after Hong Kongers lose 50% of their home values and fewer mainland visitors, our bananas will live happily thereafter.
9:49am
11:26am
1:14am
No. French racist pigs are no better than Hong Kong bananas. But mainlanders are too dumb to know that. Where there are Louis Vuitton bags and Rolex Oysters, the yellow fool and his money are soon parted.
9:10am
we do not want you here, you do nothing but make a few merchants happy
use all the infintile names you want, it does not change the fact we do not want your nose picking , line cutting , spitting kind here
italy , france, whoever - feels the same-keep pretending other countries want your money, they dont
ps. nobody we would love to replace you with japanese tourist, they respect the local culture
9:55pm
As added precaution, keep away from anti-China demonstrations. Good luck with your recovery.
Signed,
Your primary care physician
5:12am
As added precaution, keep away from anti-China demonstrations. Good luck with your recovery.
Signed,
Your primary care physician
6:08am
However, do these tourists really have to cut in line, eat on the trains, pee on the street? I've lived in Hong Kong for 20 years, and I've seen two instances of tourists from the Mainland letting their children urinate on the pavement; I'm yet to see a Hong Kong (or for that matter, any other nationality) family do the same. Yes, the majority of tourists don't engage in behaviours that crass, but it's definitely more prevalent among Mainland tourists than the Hong Kong population. We'd just like for them to be bit decent, that's all.
4:59am
You must have contracted this virus from other demonstrators at Victoria Park. Try to stay away from anti-China demonstrations. Good luck with your recovery.
In Case You Missed It
Login
SCMP.com Account
or
Log in using a partner site
Log in using your Facebook account. What's this?
Don't have an SCMP.com account? Subscribe Now!
















