• Thu
  • Dec 18, 2014
  • Updated: 7:28pm
My Take
PUBLISHED : Friday, 08 March, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Friday, 08 March, 2013, 3:48am

Hong Kong must stand up to Egypt over probe into balloon crash

Nine Hong Kong citizens died needlessly in the Luxor balloon crash, but Egyptian authorities say they don't need any foreign representative involved in their probe. This is worse than a snub; it's a blatant violation of international protocol and a lack of plain human decency.

The Hong Kong government is at fault too for not pressing its case harder or early enough. But the greater blame must lie with the Egyptian government.

It initially appeared to agree to Hong Kong's sending an aviation expert to play an advisory role. But it has now backtracked, saying that, since the investigation has started, there is no need to involve foreign representatives. Instead, it will brief Hong Kong on its progress. That's diplomat-speak for telling us to get lost. Anyway, their explanation doesn't even make sense.

What's so difficult about getting foreign experts involved? So what if the probe has started? What do the authorities in Egypt have to hide? Are they trying to whitewash an accident that killed 19 foreign tourists from countries such as Japan, Britain and France?

According to International Civil Aviation Organisation standards, "if the accident involves fatalities and injuries of citizens of other states or places, such state or place shall be entitled to appoint a representative to take part in the investigation".

The Hong Kong government is taking it on the chin and appears unwilling to press its case. But this is a perfect opportunity for our chief executive to show how tough he can be in standing up for Hong Kong's people. Hey, we are not dealing with Beijing, but Cairo.

We can afford to be assertive, even aggressive in our demand. Egypt wants our tourism business; it also needs Beijing's diplomatic support and foreign aid. We are not completely without leverage over Egypt. Leung Chun-ying should call in the consul-general and demand an explanation, or better, insist on Hong Kong's right to take part in the probe under international protocols.

If Egyptian authorities think they can restore tourism as if nothing had happened, they are sorely mistaken.

The only way they can regain trust and confidence from foreign tourists and governments is to be completely open and transparent about the investigation.


Related topics

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

Alex you are out of line on this. The investigation of air accidents is a sovereign issue and it is arrogant and offensive to suggest that we should be "aggressively" making demands to have representatives participating (other than sending one representative) in the Egyptian Government's enquiry into this disaster.
The Hong Kong's Government's own air accident investigations are less than transparent and shrouded in secrecy. There have been air fatality investigations in Hong Kong in which the results have been controversial and challenged because of disagreements over the apportionment of blame. On these occasions our Government did not invite or allow other nation's representatives to participate directly in the investigations. It is a "face" issue and nations do not like their sovereignty to be trampled over. Most countries' civil aviation authorities don't like to see their supervision of air worthiness issues and other aviation issues being portrayed in a bad light and Hong Kong has been no different in the past.There have been Government Flying Service and other operators' accidents when , in many peoples' opinion, more than a fair share of whitewash has been applied.
In case you didn't read the article, HK has the right to send a representative under ICAO standards.
Alex, with typical Hong Kong self centredness, you only mention the HK citizens who lost their lives. The other 10 dead victims included Japanese, Hungarian, French and British citizens. Don't they count?
If any experts are to be sent they should be from all the countries, and the UK and French experts are likely to be far more competent, experienced and independent than Hong Kong's. Or do you want Hong Kong experts of the standard who approved the Lamma IV vessel?

Remember that the 9 Hong Kong people died because they chose to do something that is inherently risky. I don't think the Hong Kong government really needs to get involved.
Typical Alex Lo mindless drivel. Just another one of his opportunistic pleas to jingoist paranoia.
Captam is perfectly correct on this one!
In case you didn't get the memo, Egypt is a sovereign state.


SCMP.com Account