• Fri
  • Dec 26, 2014
  • Updated: 9:35am
CommentInsight & Opinion

Pan-democrats demands for reform must be guided by reason

PUBLISHED : Monday, 25 March, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Monday, 25 March, 2013, 2:37am

Upset by the government's reluctance to make an early start on constitutional reform, pan-democrat lawmakers have stepped up the campaign with an alliance pushing for genuine universal suffrage. The next challenge for them is to come up with a clear proposal - one that stands a good chance of winning support in Beijing and Hong Kong.

Without any blueprint for a focused and informed debate, there is growing speculation as to what may or may not be implemented in 2017, when for the first time the city is due to return the chief executive by one person, one vote. The past few weeks have seen bitter disputes over the need for a screening mechanism - seen by some as a tool to shut out candidates unacceptable to Beijing. The alliance has already vowed to reject any unfair arrangements.

The pan-democrats are understandably keen to push for as liberal a regime as possible. The essence of universal suffrage is, after all, being fair and equal. This includes giving everyone the same right to elect and be elected. The ideals are also enshrined in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, whose provisions are to be implemented through local law under Article 39 of the Basic Law.

On the other hand, Article 45 stipulates that the future leader is to be elected by universal suffrage "by a broadly representative nominating committee in accordance with democratic procedures". This has been interpreted by some as a pre-screening or primary poll. It remains unclear what arrangements will be put in place. But the recent debate shows there are opposing views in society. The issue is poised to be the focus in future and warrants more serious discussions.

Like it or not, arrangements not within the constitutional framework are unlikely to be approved. The pan-democrats' call to reject "fake" democracy is probably shared by many in society. But the public also looks forward to a clear blueprint from the camp, one that has good prospects of being passed.

The alliance has been hailed as the pan-democrats' first show of unity after the rift three years ago over reforms. But whether they can stay as a united front remains to be seen. Some radical members have threatened to pull out if their demands are not met. With 27 votes in Legco, the bloc holds de facto veto power over the coming reform. To wield the biggest political influence, they should produce a feasible electoral package for public discussion.


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

hard times !
Man with reason is called a normal man and not an insane or mad man--crazy man. Of course our pan-democrats rightly demand a political reform to be guided by reason and not passion or empty words uttered.Yet these days (starting from March 8th), a Comment writer of S.C.M.P. has been continuously being attacked by a shameless nasty hacker since his e-mail address was carelessly disclosed here in the postings.This nasty guy made use of 'Netvigator', 'HSBC': Hong Kong Bank ; making every effort to trick the writer to click in an unknown/poisonous button, link or open an attached file ----so as to spread virus on his /her computer to defunction it ! How vicious this son-of-b....is ! Right ? He should be cursed forever and ever for his dirtiest trick committed as a human/beast !
"One that stands a good chance of winning support in Beijing and Hong Kong"? So the SCMP's position is that we should yield to the prerequisite so unequivocally laid down by Qian Xiao-yang that our elected CE must be a supporter of the corrupt Communist Party Government in Beijing? Party infiltration in SCMP ranks has never been more self-evident. The prospect of me renewing my SCMP subscription is waning rapidly.


SCMP.com Account