• Sat
  • Dec 20, 2014
  • Updated: 11:13am
CommentInsight & Opinion

Impartiality key in handling Mercantile Exchange case

PUBLISHED : Thursday, 23 May, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Thursday, 23 May, 2013, 4:19am

The controversy surrounding Executive Councillor Barry Cheung Chun-yuen has deepened with a police investigation into the failed Hong Kong Mercantile Exchange he set up. On Tuesday, three men, none of whom worked for Cheung, were arrested by commercial-crime investigators for possessing false documents and using a false instrument. Little information is available at this stage. But that the arrests came after "serious" irregularities were unearthed in an initial probe is disturbing. The case involves a top cabinet member of Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying. The public will be closely watching whether it will be handled in a fair manner.

There is no evidence to suggest Cheung is involved in any unlawful dealings. But the fiasco, which follows a number of controversies involving the ruling team, has dealt Leung another blow. Former development minister Mak Chai-kwong is on trial in connection with an alleged housing allowance fraud decades ago. Another cabinet member, Franklin Lam Fan-keung, has been on leave for months pending the outcome of a probe into whether he benefited from inside information when he sold properties ahead of a new stamp duty coming in.

Cheung led Leung's election campaign last year and holds multiple public offices, including the chairmanships of the Urban Renewal Authority and top advisory bodies. Inevitably, Leung's authority will be further undermined.

Yesterday, Cheung maintained that his private business should not have any negative impact on the government. Arguably, one's success or failure in business does not necessarily affect the way one's public duties are discharged. There is no cause for saying the positions held by Cheung have been compromised. But perception sometimes overrides evidence. That individuals in financial trouble are vulnerable to undue influence is just common sense. The risk is higher if they are in the corridors of power. Cheung has rightly stood aside from all his public duties for the time being. He said he was prepared to go further and resign from all positions if needed.

No one is above the law in Hong Kong. The principle must be upheld even when dealing with the rich and powerful. The chief executive said Cheung's case would be handled impartially. The ongoing investigations by the Securities and Futures Commission and the police are a good sign the principle is being followed. The case should be handled in a fair and expeditious way lest greater damage is done.


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

hard times !
it is now learnt that earlier,our financial secretary,John Tsang had insisted on investigating the battered company controlled by Barry Cheung Chun-yuen,the right-handed man of C.Y.and an Exco.member plus the chairman of Urban Renewal Bureau. Yet C.Y.might be unwilling to do so as Cheung was/is No.1 fan who vigorously supported his acension to the top post in town last year.Yet paper can never cover fire and now the fire has spread like a wild one and can never be contained----many local businessmen/women now attempt to distance themselves from Barry Cheung though they probably were once his debtors who generously lent him money to save his Hong Kong Mercantile Exchange which probably had speculated on gold futures and lost in hundreds of millions ! What a shame and a shock towards this unpopular and incapable Leung administration which may have to dissolve or step down before 2017.Just wait and see.
hard times !
Right,no one is allowed to be above law in our beloved Hong Kong which is being plagued by so many scandals recently:the former security for development,Mak Chak-kwong is being tried and Exco member,Lam Fan-keung is still on leave for being investigated by the ICAC for inside trading and now No.1 Leung fan,Barry Cheung Chun-yuen's company is being investigated by the Commercial Crime Unit and is broke already.As an Exco member who holds many public duties,this Cheung is learnt to shoulder many debts borrowed from local businessmen who might affect his policies or views in public matters.Right ? This Cheung has become the newest negative asset of the Leung team besides the director of marine who refuses to publicly apologize to the relatives of the victims in the Lamma sea disaster.Not to say the case of Timothy Tong Hin-ming and other ministers in Leung administration whose performances are far from satisfactory ! Maybe a big haul is needed by C.Y. to renew his administration for the well-being of Hong Kong and his people !


SCMP.com Account