• Sat
  • Dec 27, 2014
  • Updated: 4:35am
My Take
PUBLISHED : Thursday, 04 July, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Thursday, 04 July, 2013, 3:44am

Why I can't help sitting on the fence


Alex Lo is a senior writer at the South China Morning Post. He writes editorials and the daily “My Take” column on page 2. He also edits the weekly science and technology page in Sunday Morning Post.

Someone's got my number. A critic in a blog, which I will call "Small Melon, Various Fruits", describes my column as a "Beijing-sympathetic-but-not-pro-Communist, pluralistic-but-not-pro-dem act." I couldn't have used fewer words if I tried to explain myself to my elderly parents.

For that, he said I surely deserve a Bronze Bauhinia Star. Just bronze? I was hoping for gold, despite the precious metal's price plunge. But I doubt Leung Chun-ying, our government boss, would consider me for the august prize, given the disproportionate number of nasty columns I have devoted to rounding on his government. My fruity critic has a much more impressive routine, though, a sort of "I feel compassion for Hong Kong but only because I'm so much cleverer than the natives". We have plenty of expats with that sort of superiority complex that is constantly hinted at but a social taboo to admit to. That would be too arrogant and possibly racist now, wouldn't it?

As for my sitting on the fence, which a few readers of his blog apparently consider a sin, I can't help myself. Sorry, there are just no real communists in China to join forces with; those who still fancy themselves as such are either nutcases or nonagenarians dozing off in Zhongnanhai.

What about my failure to support the pan-dems? Well, I don't know about you, but I really find it hard to side with such old drama queens as Cardinal Joseph Zen Ze-kiun, Jimmy Lai Chee-ying and Martin Lee Chu-ming. Perhaps my blogging critic likes and admires those kiddies from Scholarism, as many in Hong Kong apparently do. As a father, I consider it bad parenting to let children spend so much time holding forth in press conferences and fighting city hall.

We live in an age of democracy and there is no rolling back the clock. But as soon as you point out there might be problems, you unfailingly hear the same comeback: "No one ever says democracy is perfect/ideal/a cure-all …." But the way some people fetishise "democracy" and brook no criticism, you kind of get the impression they really think it's godly perfection itself. Well, at least they believe in something.

My dear critic seems to believe, first and last, in his own witticisms and cynicism. There are at least some "isms" he believes in.


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

"Beijing-sympathetic-but-not-pro-Communist, pluralistic-but-not-pro-dem" - That's most of the silent 94.9999% thinking adults!
shouken the commie racist rapist is back
OK, I'm a thicko. Can someone please tell me which blog Alex is talking about?
Consistency is a hallmark for western civilization. In fact it gave rise to scientific development, at least in the science of Newtonian world. Inconsistency is always or still thought of as bad. But it is known also exist in the Nature. Chinese civilization consists full of inconsistencies rendering its underdevelopment in science. Nowadays we are witnessing more and more inconsistencies not only in Nature but in politics as well. I am more convinced that consistency is becoming less of a value judgment than a way of doing thing or behaving. An argument once I heard at work in a famous architect office in New York City in the early 80s between a Korean and an American when the former raised a question that if an action taken bore consistency but the end result was wrong would it still be alright? I have been haunted ever since. But I sensed immediately at that moment that the argument had much to do with cultural differences. Today, I am more convinced that inconsistency becomes a necessity regardless you are a Korean or an American. Nature dictates. Here, I am not suggesting Nature is always good for us. Use your judgment., Alex has been doing that all along in his column.
To captam below:
I am sorry you are bored by me. So my sincere advice to you is to stop reading my comments which always signed as johnyuan (real name). There is a saying: one responsible for one’s happiness. So I gather you do find some playing with words. Interesting?
I am sorry you are bored by me. So my sincere advice to you is to stop reading my comments which always signed as johnyuan (real name). There is a saying: one responsible for one’s ow happiness. So I gather you do find some by playing with words. Interesting?
I am sorry you are bored. Stop reading my commets. There is a saying that no one is responsble for your happiness. Or may be you are just playing words for kicks. Interesting.
PS, the mulfunctionig of the website gave me additional thought with my second comment above -- for my amusement not. Apologize to all.
Without details, any political system is you think and I think. And this is what civilization has made politics and in great extent the uncertainty is the effect of mass education. Original pure principled form remains in name. More have transformed into a concoction of many. I have lived to see democracy ideally practiced in the 60s of last century in the US to the present of its questionable form. I also have lived to see Communism in China of non-private property ownership to become capitalism of ownership of all kinds. Not the least, I even witnessed Hong Kong a colony, its last governor did all he could to bring in democracy. Political system without details can’t serve us any good. The name of a political system has more become a hindrance preventing engagement among us. In conclusion I can assure you there is no guarantee in politics. But having all said of my observation I still hope I had taken Poly (Political) Science 101 course to understand politic so to prove myself wrong that actually there is order in the world’s politic which we can depend on.




SCMP.com Account