• Sat
  • Aug 2, 2014
  • Updated: 12:04pm
CommentInsight & Opinion

Hong Kong should live up to its tag of 'world-class city'

Victoria Sung says the embrace of a Hong Kong identity should not mean rejecting the multicultural realities today, if we aspire to be 'world class'

PUBLISHED : Friday, 05 July, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Friday, 05 July, 2013, 4:56am

I attended the July 1 protests, braving the rain to observe the scene in Victoria Park. It was exciting to be in a place where civic engagement was energetic, especially when compared with my experience of living in democratic countries where politics is treated with either apathy or frustration.

But, as I walked among the other protesters, I noticed something disturbing. One of the chants taken up by the protesters was, "Hong Kong people are great!"

Hong Kong is a world-class city, or so we're told by the city's slogan. Yet at the protests on July 1, the pan-democracy movement was painting an image of Hong Kong that appeared to be very exclusionary, because it is safe to say that the "Hong Kong people" referred to in the chant excluded those who are not Han Chinese Cantonese speakers.

A truly world-class city is one that is multicultural and has a strong sense of what it means to be a citizen, regardless of race, gender or class. If Hong Kong wants to be respected on the world stage, we have to expand the definition of a Hongkonger.

The refusal to acknowledge those who are not Chinese Cantonese speakers as Hongkongers is dangerous. It is understandable that people are afraid of losing what is unique about Hong Kong - it was reflected in the uproar over the 2008 Olympics announcements being made in Putonghua and not Cantonese.

But the issue goes beyond language. It was truly shocking to see the hatred in public opinion aimed at the Filipino domestic workers who sought Hong Kong residency after living in the city for 25 years. The popular view is that Hongkongers "allow" workers from other countries to come here and that migrant workers are "privileged" to work here.

It is an attitude that would not be readily tolerated elsewhere.

To illustrate this, just replace "Hong Kong" with any other nationality or race. "White people are great!" The result is something that sounds supremacist. To say that one ethnicity or race is superior to others is patriotism at its most extreme.

If we are to say Hong Kong is a world-class city, we cannot stand for this sort of supremacy or intolerance. We have to be more open about what it means to be a Hongkonger.

Throughout history, it has been demonstrated time and time again that people become more fearful and discriminatory during uncertain times. A recent example is the increasingly difficult situation of North African and Arab immigrants living in Europe. Prioritising one group of citizens over another is not simply a matter of pride. The promotion of supremacy, be it of Cantonese-speaking Han Chinese or any other ethnic group, can easily lead to the discrimination and even persecution of minority groups.

Hong Kong has yet to achieve the confidence to exist without the fear of others diluting our cultural identity. We have to ask ourselves: do we really want Hong Kong to stay the way it is? Or, should we continue to evolve and follow the global trend of becoming more multicultural, multiracial and tolerant of differences?

Victoria Sung holds a master's degree in media, culture and communications from New York University and is the founder of Meanwhile in China


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

" saying HK people are great is like saying Americans are great" -- totally agree! In addition, it is only when we're proud of who 'we' are, then we can start to accept and appreciate what 'others' are adding to our identity and culture.
On the other hand though, I believe there are still a sizable population here who cannot accept that those who are from a different race can be a Hongkonger too. I think this is what the author is trying to criticize.
Honk kong really needs to give up on the "World Class" title game because it will never attain that, for whatever it means. I believe it's already a subjective fact that Singapore is Asia's "World City". With insular, provincial thinking and an economy based on money laundering RMB, smuggling and tax free shopping for mainlanders, HK isn't going to cut it.
However, As long as places like shanghai restrict the free flow of information vital to becoming a financial center and is still under the Great Firewall of the CCP then HK will be a base for international corporations in Asia. God forbid that and high luxury goods taxes ends!
Instead HK should concentrate on its strengths and aim for a more realistic mantra...something like "Hong Kong: China's most information accessible city - until the triads intimidate opposition voices from ever speaking out again.", "Hong Kong: low, low personal taxes" or "Hong Kong: At least It's not Shenyang"
Huh? She's joking right? Coming from NY too.
- Chanting HK People are great is not the same as chanting Cantonese speaking people are great.
- Agree Hongkongers should be proud of HK, so people who want residency, do they want to be Hongkongers or just want residency? HK is a city-country, not enough space to open immigration gates and undo mistakes. No different than Singapore.
- White people are Great? No, saying HK people are great is like saying Americans are great.
- Not tolerated elsewhere? Look at the country where you studied, and tell me it doesn't exist. or in Japan. or elsewhere. Just because it's passive, hidden, accepted, doesn't mean it doesn't exist. motherhood statement.
Singapore is Asia's World City only because of better PR/marketing. Really? No problem, HK will take Cathay's slogan... Hong Kong - the Heart of Asia...
But they let people in from pretty much every nation.
"Hong Kong: At least it's not Shenyang."
Hong Kong is great and a worldclass city. Yes, that the outside view (or at least should). What is in the inside? A overpriced, unreasonable expensive city with small living space and area (on purpose), bad educational curricl. compared to international standards, and with people who easily discriminate others Non-Hongkongnese (Non-Cantonese Speaker). That is the reality so the slogan "Hong Kong People are great" does actually only meant for those.


SCMP.com Account