• Thu
  • Aug 21, 2014
  • Updated: 7:55pm
CommentInsight & Opinion

Save Hong Kong from its naysayers

Mak Kwok Wah says we need to banish the pettiness and negativism pervading politics and the media, lest Hong Kong lose its dynamism

PUBLISHED : Thursday, 29 August, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Thursday, 29 August, 2013, 3:36am

On the occasion of Singapore's national day this month, its prime minister, Lee Hsien Loong, delivered a speech containing some important points that Hong Kong's critics should seriously reflect upon.

Lee drew attention to the achievements of the island republic, such as its efficient infrastructure and social welfare policy. But what might have escaped the attention of many was his call for gotong royong - a Malay expression describing how a community mobilises itself to help one another.

Lee cited Singapore's Malay community as setting a good example to follow with their strong spirit of gotong royong. In particular, he pointed out how members of Malay-Muslim organisations are joining hands to meet socio-economic needs. This has brought significant improvements to Malay Singaporeans, including higher incomes and better education standards, and Lee urged other community groups to follow suit and do more to help one another.

Like Singapore, Hong Kong is a shining example of a small territory with minimal natural assets that by sheer determination - plus the ingenuity of its leaders and the sweat of its masses - wrought an economic miracle. To accomplish this "Hong Kong miracle", we bonded and worked together to get the job done, however tough it was.

We should ask ourselves whether we are happy with our life, and whether we are enjoying far better conditions than did our parents or grandparents when they migrated here from the mainland. For most, the answer to these questions would be "yes".

Though some of us seem to forget, Hong Kong has a lot going for it: a sizeable public housing scheme, an independent and effective judicial system, and low tax rates.

There are still job opportunities in Hong Kong, plus cheap and efficient public transport, a fairly high standard of living for most, not to mention its safe environment, one of safest in the world.

Despite all these advantages, a dark cloud of negativism grips the minds of a highly vocal minority. To some of these naysayers, our government is blind or at least short-sighted. Sadly, most of this negative criticism occurs in the Legislative Council, where some radical members are always trying to obstruct government proposals and turn the minds of the community against its every decision.

Hong Kong has always prided itself on its get-up-and-go spirit. So what has dragged these naysayers into such despondency and despair?

If the qualities of gotong royong sound familiar to some old Hongkongers, it is because we used to have them in spades - our renowned "can-do" attitude, plus the communal spirit that marked our parents' and grandparents' generations. This is also why some media commentators lament that Hong Kong has lost its mojo.

If we are to recapture it, we must first eliminate the poison of petty politics and negativism pervading society. Let's see a change in Legco from the present atmosphere of obstructionism to one where everyone pulls together to get things done. And let's not allow some of the media, which abides by the adage of "bad news is good news", to dictate the tone of our conversation.

Mak Kwok Wah is a public affairs consultant

Share

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive
 
 

 

13

This article is now closed to comments

boondeiyan
No surprises here: 38 years as a government flack shines through. By all means let SCMP give this line of argument its time in the spotlight. But how about striking a blow for intellectual discourse by letting some "radical" Legco member e.g. KH Leung have a chance at making a counterpoint? Surely we don't need to pay a newspaper to bring us information that the government provides for free; at least for another 34 years...
Dai Muff
The people are not the problem. The fact that their aspirations and hopes are constantly being diminished is. And no we do not need our media to all sing from the same government-praising choir-sheet as Singapore's media does.
johnyuan
‘Though some of us seem to forget, Hong Kong has a lot going for it: a sizeable public housing scheme, an independent and effective judicial system, and low tax rates’. Hardly. Conditions have changed. The population in Hong Kong’s developing stage was only a fraction of the current. The ‘nagativism’ is a response to those early social measures which retrograded to become mirages for the majority. Their values only hold true in history. Only reform, socially and politically can make Hong Kong vibrant again since it still inhabited by the same industrial and intelligent people albeit a lot more. It is really a disservice to Hong Kong for this writer to blame others but not seeing one’s own fault for his claim of 'nagativism'. Especially without pointing out that new environment requires new measure. Stop singing the past glory like a broken record repeating endlessly. Reform and move on.
……
Hong Kong without reform will become irrelevant to the rest of the world including mainland China. Hong Kong doesn’t even have a casino to stay relevant?

Pages

 
 
 
 
 

Login

SCMP.com Account

or