• Fri
  • Dec 19, 2014
  • Updated: 1:52am
My Take
PUBLISHED : Friday, 15 November, 2013, 3:36am
UPDATED : Friday, 15 November, 2013, 3:36am

It is time to attend to the poor and needy in Hong Kong

I once "lectured" Leung Chun-ying on the need to introduce early democratic reform to salvage his troubled administration. The chief executive promptly cut me off and curtly said the needs of the elderly and poor are far more urgent.

I actually agreed with him, but I am afraid we as a community have, justifiably or not, decided that the defence of political rights takes precedence over social welfare and entitlement protection for the needy. In fact, we think heritage protection and environmental - "green" - causes are more important than the need to tackle poverty. Why is that?

There is a fascinating chapter on these "choices" we made collectively from the 1980s onwards in a new book, Poverty in the Midst of Affluence: How Hong Kong Mismanaged Its Prosperity by the brilliant Leo Goodstadt, who gave a talk yesterday on the subject at the Foreign Correspondents Club. The three post-handover administrations may have been progressively discredited and brought into disrepute, but the traditional government stance against what may be called creeping welfarism, a narrative we inherit from the British colonials, remains dominant in our community. To be fair, Leung actually worries about such issues and has launched some welfare initiatives, unlike his two predecessors.

You would think the welfare advocacy for the poor would be a classic agenda for both the pan-democratic camp such as the Democratic Party and the leading pro-Beijing unions like the Federation of Trade Unions. As it is, neither side has been particularly active in developing an anti-poverty agenda; hence Goodstadt's chapter title - An absence of advocates: how the welfare lobby lost its voice.

Remember between 1 and 1.2 million Hong Kong people live in poverty and f ace the grim realities that the more privileged among us never have to worry about. Goodstadt's key argument is that the severity of their neglect and suffering is mainly created by the government both before and after the handover because we loath to spend on welfare. But I think the dominant political parties are also to blame because besides piecemeal solutions, no party has made anti-poverty its platform. It's time to change that; our conscience demands it.


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

Break the property lobby first, then affordability for homes and small businesses will follow.
This will not happen of course, because CY Leung's administration is just as riddled with special interests as previous ones, only worse, it is now allowing the triads free reign.
Let LKS -- our superman in town to take the lead in solving poverty in Hong Kong. He is fully qualified to do so and not the least I urge him to think about the virtue in returning and sharing his wealth among the poor in Hong Kong.
It will be a new beginning I hope for life without property as an engine that drives Hong Kong's existence. Don't just roll sugar balls in sugar water?
Alex Lo wants the government to reduce poverty?? Let me know an example of this having been a good idea. Anywhere. Ever. Asking bureaucrats to help the poor is like letting wolfs look after a herd of sheep. A government's only desire is to steal, destroy and criminalize wealth creation, resulting in poverty and despair. This is not an opinion but a consequence of basic logic and any other stand would be an oxymoron. During the 1960s the real wage for Hong Kong industrial workers doubled and severe poverty was reduced from 50% to 16%. And this at a time with less government interference than in any other part of the world in the last 100 years.
Sorry but a massive chunk of his wealth goes to another city: Shantou. Guess ancestral hometowns play more than the place that gave him wealth.
Plus, he's slowly and incrementally cashing out his chips in HK anyway.


SCMP.com Account