• Thu
  • Dec 18, 2014
  • Updated: 8:37am

Typhoon Haiyan

Typhoon Haiyan, one of the strongest storms ever recorded, struck the Philippines in November 2013 with winds of up to 190 mph (305 kph). At least 10,000 people died in one Philippine province alone.

CommentInsight & Opinion

When Typhoon Haiyan struck, moral leadership was required in Hong Kong

Bernard Chan says we should have put hostage issue aside more quickly

PUBLISHED : Thursday, 28 November, 2013, 6:46pm
UPDATED : Friday, 29 November, 2013, 3:13am

I am vice-chairman of Oxfam Hong Kong. When the first news came through of the devastation caused by Typhoon Haiyan in the Philippines, I took a special interest in seeing how local charities would respond.

Normally, locally based relief agencies react to disasters like Haiyan by quickly seeking donations from the public and using those funds to aid victims. On this occasion, however, at least some locally based charities say they initially felt uncertain about what to do. The public mood seemed hostile towards the Philippines, owing to the ongoing dispute over apologies and compensation for the 2010 Manila bus hostage tragedy.

Hong Kong carried on demanding a response while [others] rushed to offer help

The shootings of those innocent Hong Kong people in Manila were shown live on TV, and were a huge shock to this community.

It is understandable that the public here supported calls for apologies and compensation from the Philippines - even if it was perhaps unrealistic to expect a foreign government to meet such requests. It was hardly surprising that some of our local politicians got involved in providing assistance to victims' families.

It was extremely unfortunate, however, that this controversy grew into such a big issue just as a massive humanitarian disaster struck the Philippines. The international media noticed, and reported how Hong Kong carried on demanding a response from Manila while the rest of the world rushed to offer sympathy and help.

In retrospect, our politicians should have taken a clearer lead and immediately and publicly put the bus issue to one side. In fairness to our officials, there were delicate behind-the-scenes negotiations going on with Manila counterparts around that time. More than anything else, however, they found themselves facing a possibly ugly public mood.

In media interviews I gave as more details of the disaster started to come in, I suggested that Hong Kong suspend its threatened "ultimatum" for a while. It seemed a reasonable thing to say. But the reaction on one newspaper's blog and elsewhere was vicious. When I pointed out that Filipino domestic helpers make a major contribution to many Hong Kong families, some responded that it is Hong Kong that helps them.

In effect, the mood was unpleasant, selfish and uncaring. Charities couldn't be sure that if they made appeals for donations, the Hong Kong public would respond as generously as usual.

However, the story gets better. There were soon signs that the insensitivity we saw was not universal or even typical. Within days of the disaster, our officials were acting swiftly to get Legislative Council approval for HK$40 million government funds to help the Philippines. Oxfam Hong Kong launched a HK$500,000 drive, which has since gone on to attract millions in donations. Major companies quickly announced big donations, and Indonesian and Filipino residents were collecting money. Individual donations were soon coming in. Then stories started to circulate about Hong Kong employers giving their Filipino helpers loans, donations and time off to help families back home.

In short, just as things seemed quite depressing, Hong Kong's generous and compassionate side came through. I am glad to say that, so far as I can see, the insensitive and callous attitudes displayed in the first few days of the disaster reflected an angry and sometimes publicity-seeking minority, not mainstream Hong Kong.

There is an important lesson here. With emotions running high over the bus tragedy, people seemed uncertain what to do or say. But when it comes to a clear moral issue like helping neighbours in distress, our government leaders, politicians, media and other opinion-makers have to take a public stand and do it quickly.

Bernard Chan is a member of the Executive Council

Share

Related topics

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive
 
 

 

 
 
 
 
 
5

This article is now closed to comments

caractacus
Our leaders showed that they are not big enough to take a moral stand and instead, at least for a while, pandered to the mean spirited bigots and unscrupulous political opportunists like Albert Chan Wai Yip, James To Kun Sun and Regina Ip Lau Suk Yee, all of whom profess to be Christians. Perhaps only Chinese Christians count with them.
SUPERMUM
Philippine President laughed about the victims of HK hostage, police and citizens took photos in front of the broken bus, they're really impolite to victims! Year history today ~
SUPERMUM
IT'S AQUINO OWES THEM PENSION AND APOLOGIES ,you wont understand , WHY COZ , YOU HAVEN'T SEEN IN YOUR OWN EYES , WHEN IN FRONT OF YOU YOUR FAMILY BEING SHOT BUT GUNS AND BEING KILLED IN A FOREIGN NEIGHBOUR COUNTRY ,YET WHO ORDERED THE SPECIAL FORCE TO KILLING MODE ? WHO IS INCHARGE OF ORDERING AND KILLING ARE THE ONE'S RESPONSIBLE.
SUPERMUM
HKSAR government is releasing HK$50,000,000 for application by relief agents for helping the disaster victims in Philippines. In contrast, Aquino would not even give HK$200,000 claimed pension to Mendoza to prevent the latter from murdering/wounding dozens of innocent HK tourists in Manila in 2010. Furthermore, the compensation is being sought by the Manila HK hostages, not HK people or HK government. Do your homework before discrediting anyone again. Otherwise, it only reflects on you yourself.
SUPERMUM
Hongkongers are not harsh cold, but President of the Philippines talked with smiling about HK tourist victims' tragedy, while the Philippines has this fool down in HK and the HK suffer insults, so it is inevitable that Hongkongers cannot bring compassion.

Login

SCMP.com Account

or