• Sat
  • Dec 27, 2014
  • Updated: 11:10pm
CommentInsight & Opinion

China risks being left behind unless it builds a web that's open to all

Anne Jellema says a freer, more accessible internet can serve China in many ways, not least by making it more competitive and innovative, the key to achieving its 'Chinese Dream'

PUBLISHED : Monday, 09 December, 2013, 5:21am
UPDATED : Monday, 09 December, 2013, 5:21am

Last month saw the launch of this year's World Wide Web Foundation annual Web Index report, which is the world's first measure of the web's contribution to social, economic and political development in 81 countries.

Sweden topped the rankings, ahead of Norway. South Korea, at No 10, was the highest-placed Asian country.

China, however, is being fast outpaced - even by smaller countries such as Costa Rica, Colombia and the Philippines - in harnessing the web to accelerate development and innovation. Ranking 57, it is the country that World Wide Web inventor Sir Tim Berners-Lee identified as showing the most room for improvement.

There are two main issues China must address to improve its performance and remain competitive in a fast-digitising world. First, China needs to do much more to make the internet affordable and accessible for everyone.

In the Web Index category that measures whether countries have invested in affordable access to high-quality internet infrastructure, as well as investing in the education and skills citizens need to use the web well, China is placed above countries such as Saudi Arabia, India, Indonesia and Morocco.

However, for the 359 million Chinese citizens who live on US$2 a day or less, access to mobile or fixed broadband is out of reach - costing between 25 per cent and 38 per cent of their monthly income.

Second, China must deal with the challenge of privacy and freedom online. The Web Index report found that China censors web content extensively and has no meaningful safeguards against online spying by security agencies.

As Edward Snowden has made clear, this can no longer be considered a developing-world problem alone: the Web Index also highlights the United States, Canada, Britain, Australia, New Zealand and Sweden, among others, for "inadequate" safeguards against government spying. However, only Saudi Arabia and Vietnam were placed below China on the index measure of freedom and openness online.

China's cybercafes are now 40 per cent owned by chains, which are easier for authorities to regulate than independent businesses. In the past year, traffic on virtual private networks (VPNs) - used to bypass censorship - has been disrupted, sometimes obstructing commercial use; regulators ordered online video services to censor short films in July 2012, when users adopted them to bypass film and broadcast restrictions; security agents in Tibet and Xinjiang have searched cellphones to pre-empt allegedly anti-state activity; and a Criminal Procedure Law amendment took effect in January, strengthening legal grounds for detaining anti-state suspects incommunicado.

This is, of course, a concern for those who believe that the government must begin to extend basic civil liberties in order for it to maintain legitimacy and stability in the face of rising social tensions.

Regardless of the form of government practised, it is important for citizens in any country to have outlets to discuss concerns, complain and protest - and increasingly, citizens seek those outlets online.

Pervasive surveillance and censorship should also be a worry for those who question whether China can move up the value chain fast enough to remain competitive - a transition that requires harnessing the full power of the open web to catalyse greater innovation and creativity.

The "Chinese Dream" requires building a web that is accessible to all and that can power innovation and creativity in political, social and economic spheres. Step by step, website by website, family by family, China must become a part of the World Wide Web's global conversation.

We hope the research in the index can help campaigners, policymakers and also the Chinese government to understand the scale of the task ahead.

Anne Jellema is chief executive officer of the World Wide Web Foundation. Established by Sir Tim Berners-Lee, the foundation webfoundation.org seeks to establish the open web as a global public good and a basic right


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

The Chinese are some of the shrewdest people in the world and think long-term. You can see this from their emergence since 1980 when their GDP was a mere US$202 billion (2012 prices) and where now by 2023 it is projected to be US$ 20,000 billion (a 100 fold increase). People should never underestimate the Chinese and what they are capable of doing.Indeed although China in a lot of people's minds is still in the 'copying stage' of technologies, they are no different to many SE Asian countries that went through this phase also and then advanced into building there own technologies. Japan in particular here and where even Singapore in the 1960s after their independence were living in abject poverty. Now they have one of the highest average per capita incomes in the world, the far better indicator of a nation's wealth than GDP. The Chinese leadership appear to know what is best for their economy and if opening up the web to its people is advantageous in economic terms, they will do it. Indeed as China is the highest owner of foreign reserves in the world heading up to US$5 trillion with a mere 10% Debt to GDP, they can literally do anything. In this respect also I remember an Asian businessman saying ten years ago, "you (the West) have your billionaires, we shall have the first trillionaire". It appears that his prediction may come true in time. Overall people underestimate the Chinese at their peril, WWW or not.
Dr David Hill
Chief Executive
World Innovation Foundation
It is not the Chinese economy that you have to learn about but more importantly the Chinese mind. Understand that and you understand where China is going.
Dr David Hill
World Innovation Foundation
It seems that the Chinese government does not know what is best for the Chinese people! This is evident by the continuing smog problems China continues to experience. Sadly the Chinese govt has the nerve to suggest that smog is very helpful for defense of the country! The example that was used was the war in Kosovo and how fires lit in Serbia hindered US military air operations there. Up to now I just didn't understand how those fires led to the bombing of the Chinese Embassy there. I appreciate the clarification! As to the world wide web, your readers are correct about the need for a free and open internet for the Chinese cyber-user community. It is time to really enter the 21rst century and for the Chinese government to stop hiding behind the traditional repression of free ideas and free discourse in cyber-space and among yourselves in private and public settings!
When China closed itself to the world, while the Western powers used their technologically advanced ships, maps and navigation, China was left behind, eventually making it weak and ripe for domination. The Internet is the new technology that will leave China behind as well. To make a Chinese youtube or Fb serves no purpose. Go to youtube and once you get past the cat videos you will see people in Korea displaying their invention or iPhone app, Companies demonstrating products, people singing songs, etc...or whatever. You can see things from all over the world, but you will not see anything from China, because most Chinese cannot access. As the world gets close, China is once agin, sealing itself off.
Donate Bitcoin address: 1Ez22vkV8SdM6aeJ1rJGpGYP81FAtCFG7C
Seems you have a lot to learn about the structure of the Chinese economy...


SCMP.com Account