• Thu
  • Apr 17, 2014
  • Updated: 9:42pm
CommentInsight & Opinion

Safety must be a priority as China bolsters Pakistan nuclear energy push

Syed Fazl-e-Haider considers its Chinese-aided energy development

PUBLISHED : Monday, 09 December, 2013, 6:45pm
UPDATED : Tuesday, 10 December, 2013, 2:15am

China is strengthening Pakistan's nuclear muscle in a bid to overcome the South Asian nation's energy crisis. After helping to develop the nuclear facility in Chashma, in Punjab province, China is now working with Pakistan on another plant in the southern port city of Karachi.

This is not just a move by Pakistan's strategic ally to help Islamabad overcome its crippling power shortages; it is also a move by an ambitious nuclear power seeking to enhance its nuclear trade abroad.

The Karachi plant will be Pakistan's largest nuclear power project, with a production capacity of 2,200 megawatts. Late last month, Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif inaugurated the project, which is estimated to cost US$9.6 billion. The project, which involves setting up two nuclear reactors, is scheduled to be completed in six years.

Certainly, it will be difficult for the cash-strapped country to raise the funds for the project and the government is having to rely largely on foreign loans. Energy security is the top priority of the government, which plans to increase the share of nuclear power in electricity production by installing nuclear power plants with a total capacity of 8,800MW by 2030. The country also plans to construct six more nuclear power plants with the capacity to produce 40,000MW of electricity by 2050 with China's co-operation.

Presently, the country has two nuclear power plants - Chashma 1 and 2 - each with a capacity of 300MW and built with Chinese assistance.

Chashma 3 and 4 are being built with the co-operation of China Zhongyuan Engineering Corporation, which is directly affiliated to the state-run China National Nuclear Corp.

Yet, while the Karachi project will help the country meet its energy needs, it also raises safety concerns, given its location on the Arabian Sea coast, about 40 kilometres west of Karachi.

The 2011 Japanese earthquake and tsunami, which triggered a nuclear crisis, raised a global alarm about atomic safety. The construction of nuclear plants along coastlines has long been considered risky.

Therefore, an environmental impact assessment must be carried out before the Karachi facilities are built. In particular, it must be determined whether the complex is located in a seismic zone.

Even with its advanced technology, Japan faced a potential catastrophe after the quake-crippled nuclear power plant exploded, releasing low levels of radiation.

Certainly, for a country that faces chronic power shortages affecting its industrial output, daily life and economic growth, the nuclear power projects are a blessing for Pakistan. Yet, it seems that business interests dominate safety concerns at present.

China sees the development of nuclear sites in Pakistan as a showcase of its ability to export reactors, a trade that Beijing hopes will grow. Chinese nuclear industry executives see abundant opportunities to expand their nuclear power sector abroad.

But critics have objected in particular to the 1970s technology being used by China to build the Chashma reactors, claiming it has fewer safety features than the newer models Beijing is set to use for its domestic nuclear plants.

China currently has 17 nuclear power reactors in operation, with another 28 under construction - some 40 per cent of the world's total currently being built.

China is particularly proud of having completed the latest 1,000MW reactor at the Ling Ao power plant in Guangdong, which became operational in 2011, in 57 months. How will it fare in Pakistan?

Syed Fazl-e-Haider is a development analyst in Pakistan



This article is now closed to comments

Pakistan is a politically unstable country with rampant corruption and elements of its security forces are giving support to the Taliban extremists. The political leaders play a double game at this, playing off the ignorant religious fanatics against the rational citizens while accepting up to US$4 billion a year in military and civil aid from the USA.
China is buying the country with its offers of economic aid. It is not doing this for nothing. Part of the "agreement" is that all the materials and labour for the project come from China and China controls the installations when built. One day, Pakistanis will wake up and find that their country has been taken over by Chinese who will strip their natural resources and exploit them to the hilt.
Pakistan has no idea who its real friends are and its political leaders, corrupt beyond imagination, are betraying their country into the hands of a foreign power which will undermine and destroy the people's democratic freedoms and civil liberties.
U.S. relationship with Pakistan "could not be more important" as Islamabad struggles with economic, security and regional stability issues. Pakistan is one of the four nuclear armed states (along with India, Israel, and North Korea) that is in good standing of the International Atomic Energy Agency. Also the nuclear plant safety of Pakistan has been assessed by experts from International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and World Association of Nuclear Operators (WANO). and they are satisfied.
Rubbish. Pakistan's government is totally corrupt and no assurances about its nuclear ****nal can be trusted.
There is a dire for Pakistan to overcome the energy crisis. for that reason cooperation between Pakistan and China in the field of sharing nuclear power plants to Pakistan will open new opportunities and help in extending relations in other sectors as well. as fas the safety and security of nuclear power plants are concerned, it a fact that pakistan's safety and security command structure is robust and strong. There is no doubt regarding the security measures and mechanisms of Pakistan. And it would definately be able to counter any kind of natural hazards to the nuclear power plants.
Bo llo cks. You are talking through your a r s e.
Pakistan is suffering with massive power crisis. The depleting energy resources have created further fears among the masses. Unfortunately, nuclear power only contributes 3% to the total production. To curb the power crisis Pakistan must invest in nuclear power generation. Earlier nuclear power plants have been build according to the IAEA standards. So the new power plants will be on same standards. Chinese assistance in nuclear power for peaceful purposes is quite appreciable in this regard.
Pakistan has unearthed all the stones to make its nuclear safety and security apparatus stringent. Therefore, it must be understand that Pakistan civil nuclear capabilities are under safe control. Its security mechanism is so much extensive and deliberates that it can preempt as well as prevent any natural or physical catastrophe in future.


SCMP.com Account