Advertisement
Opinion
Alex Lo

My Take | A news junkie can't get his fix in China

A pan-democrat reader once taunted me: "If you love China so much, why don't you go live on the mainland?" As much as I love the motherland, I can't live without the American and British news media, and you only have limited access to them across the border. 

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
News media such as The New York Times are regularly blocked wholesale for long periods or censored on individual stories on the mainland.
Alex Loin Toronto

A pan-democrat reader once taunted me: "If you love China so much, why don't you go live on the mainland?"

As much as I love the motherland, I can't live without the American and British news media, and you only have limited access to them across the border. You learn to discount their US-centric bias, which is a minor irritant. I know this is an unpatriotic thing to say. But while I could conceivably do without HBO on pay TV, as a news junkie, I just can't function without The New York Times, Bloomberg, BBC, Reuters and The Wall Street Journal (sans its right-wing editorials). They are regularly blocked wholesale for long periods or censored on individual stories.

Beijing has apparently declared war on these news groups. The visa applications of more than 20 journalists from The New York Times and Bloomberg, according to the Times' columnist Thomas Friedman, have been held up, apparently in retaliation for their digging into the massive wealth allegedly amassed by the close relatives and associates of some of the nation's top leaders. Many experts believe Beijing was angered because that crossed a red line.

Advertisement

Well, I am no sinologist but those stories in the past two years exposing the dodgy official wealth are among the best reporting I have seen.

But why weren't those stories exposed by Hong Kong and Taiwanese journalists and their organisations when they are closer to the source without the pressure of official censorship to which their mainland counterparts are subject.

Advertisement

At this point, my pan-democrat critics will scream, "self-censorship". I am sure there is an element of that.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x