• Fri
  • Dec 26, 2014
  • Updated: 12:18pm
My Take
PUBLISHED : Friday, 02 May, 2014, 3:49am
UPDATED : Friday, 02 May, 2014, 5:08am

Japanese psyche reflected in monsters

In his masterpiece Embracing Defeat, US historian John Dower gives a panoramic view of post-war Japan, from the books and movies ordinary people read and watch to high policy conflicts between Tokyo and Washington. Yet, in hundreds of pages, there is not a single mention of Godzilla, the influential 1954 classic about the giant reptile that came to embody the Japanese mistrust of science, fear of nuclear annihilation and anti-Americanism.

No, I am not talking about the latest Hollywood 3-D version which has the reptile's diehard fans in Japan up in arms because it has grown too fat.

The 60th-anniversary digital restoration of Godzilla: The Japanese Original has just been released. The original is as much about the wounded Japanese psyche as it's about the country's love-hate relationship with its American conqueror-cum-liberator. It is like Mary Shelley's Frankenstein and Bram Stoker's Dracula. They arose out of primal fear but have early on been turned into kitschy remakes, their real psychic disturbance neutered by commercialism.

The movie's original Japanese viewers in 1954 would have instantly recognised the references of Godzilla's radioactive fire-breathing, its awakening from the deep sea by a nuclear weapon test and its merciless destruction of Tokyo. Earlier that year, the news was full of reports about a Japanese crew that was exposed to massive radiation after their fishing boat strayed into a US nuclear bomb-testing zone off the Bikini Atoll. Memories of the fire-bombing of Tokyo by the Americans, as well as of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, were still fresh in audiences' minds. The movie's special effects director cut his teeth by building war-planning models for the Japanese military during the second world war.

The movie was bought by American distributors who promptly removed all the anti-American and nuclear-war references, and inserted a dodgy American character to make it more "audience-friendly" during the McCarthy era.

With the rise of China and the fear it provokes in Japan, you wonder if a comparable monster or apparition will appear from the collective artistic unconscious of the Japanese.

After Godzilla, what Chinese monster awaits the Japanese?


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

How About
Good take Alex! Gojira bought over by the boogeyman that created it, as if the irony isn't strong enough, anglicised it into Godzilla! Believe me when one has skeletons in the closet or in a shrine somewhere, the monsters will keep coming!
the original godzilla film is strangely disturbing and filled with unease, probably because its scenes of death and decay are an exact mirror of what happened in hiroshima and nagasaki only a few years prior.
the new american remake looks like it is at least keeping some of the nuclear subtext and japanese background, although its sure to amp up the action for today's audiences
As long as Godzilla breath Nuclear fire, invulnerable to all human type weapons
(No puny human missile/maser should leave a mark on the Big G! Unless its made from the bones of a dead Godzilla or from aliens!)>
Also must crush all in his path! NO KAIJU SHALL REMAIN STANDING EXCEPT GODZILLA!!!


SCMP.com Account