• Sun
  • Dec 28, 2014
  • Updated: 2:54am
PUBLISHED : Wednesday, 25 June, 2014, 9:28am
UPDATED : Thursday, 26 June, 2014, 1:02am

The lesson from Dov Charney: rudeness in business never pays

Politeness costs little yet it pays dividends in the long run by way of profits and business stability

I bet you have come across a really nasty boss who thinks that the louder he shouts (it's usually a he) the more he'll be listened to and who believes that politeness is for wimps.

The movie mogul Sam Goldwyn was an archetype of this species and it is often said that the only reason so many people turned up at his funeral was they wanted to make sure he was dead.

No wonder his studio's films portrayed the hold-no-hostages bosses as great figures. In fact, many people still believe in this vision and think that being nice in running businesses is for the fairies.

The customer is always king but they need to act like kings to be treated as such

Well, it seems as though things are changing as was seen last week when Dov Charney, the widely disliked and embarrassing chairman of American Apparel, was booted out of the company he founded. The board declared that his behaviour had become "materially damaging".

Some people argue that a thin line separates being tough and aggressive and being rude but in my experience the line is not thin at all. However, there is no simple way of drawing that line; it's a bit like trying to describe an elephant which may be difficult in theory but easy enough as it approaches you.

Personally I can't abide rudeness; indeed as I get older I find it more intolerable. This came to mind when a long-term, albeit somewhat erratic customer, sent me a highly offensive e-mail littered with swear words. It could be argued that I should have ignored it and clung on to his business. Instead I sent a brief reply saying although I valued his patronage I had no intention of being addressed in this foul manner and would not respond to this kind of language.

The customer is always king but they need to act like kings to be treated as such.

And this works both ways because it is far easier to cut off relations with a rude supplier but more tricky to deal with rude customers or indeed the haughty and rude regulators who plague the catering business. Sometimes you just have to ignore your feelings and press on with these people but they never get the best out of the companies on the receiving end of this treatment.

At one extreme in my trade you hear tales of chefs spitting in the dishes of rude bosses and rude customers (I assure you this does not happen in my establishments) but more often you hear about how rude customers become the victims of elaborate manoeuvres to give them the worst of what's on offer.

It costs so little to be polite and it pays such big dividends. Moreover it leads to business stability. My company has formed long-term relationships with most of our business partners; this is based on cordial personal ties that both sides have nurtured. Not only does it lead to a certain degree of consistency but it also produces the kind of give and take that makes these relationships so profitable for both sides.

I'm not sure how you put this on a spreadsheet but I do know, for example, that if we unexpectedly run out of something or other it is likely that the supplier will make an extra effort to deliver new supplies regardless of their delivery schedule.

The benefits of good behaviour are more obvious when customers turn into loyal long-term patrons offering repeat business because they feel they are respected and know they will be treated above and beyond the norm.

Just this week I investigated a new bread and pastry supplier, whose products have a good reputation. For some reason there was only a limited range of products available when I went to see them. I asked about other products and was told with a disinterested shrug that they weren't there.

Fair enough but the saleswoman had many options for letting me know what else could be available. I debated for a couple of seconds whether to press the matter but decided not to bother as life is too short to deal with people who can't be bothered. Who knows whether a politer response might have led to developing a new business relationship but I'm not losing any sleep worrying about it.

This is probably the view taken by the board of American Apparel, which must have appreciated Charney's considerable retailing capabilities but finally decided that they could not afford the cost of his rudeness.

It's really very simple: politeness and thoughtfulness works wonders.

Stephen Vines runs companies in the food sector and moonlights as a journalist and broadcaster


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

And people are more willing to pay a little more for service with a smile and when you are treated well.
Good lord, Dov Charney was more than a bad boss. He created a chronically hostile work environment, especially for women, but also for more "normal" men made uncomfortable by their employer's aggressively obnoxious behavior. At the very, very least, Charney is guilty of serial sexual harassment. He's a sick puppy who should not be allowed to escape with a golden parachute.
Speaking of sick, what does this tell us about contemporary capitalism? Simple: As long as you're making money for the shareholders, depraved behavior short of mass murder is acceptable. When American Apparel's profits dip, all of a sudden somebody with power notices that Charney is a pervert.
But nobody can trust that Chefs don't spit in the food of nasty customers, whether they work for you or not. It is not a bad thing that there is just a chance that they will. The thought of it just might may some more polite and hence happier. People, I think, are more happy if they are polite to others. Rude people are unhappy people.
And sometimes you just need to walk away. There are customers and suppliers alike who think they are God's given gift to the world. And the farther you get away from them, the happier you'll be. Narcissism and arrogance, watch for it, identify it, and run the hell away. And be polite about it while you escape :)


SCMP.com Account