• Mon
  • Sep 15, 2014
  • Updated: 3:50pm
PUBLISHED : Monday, 28 July, 2014, 3:08am
UPDATED : Monday, 28 July, 2014, 3:08am

Quiet diplomacy now needed to advance political reform

Alice Wu says after all the bluster, it's time the moderates meet to shape an electoral reform plan, behind closed doors if necessary

The pan-democrats have called for direct talks with Beijing to break the deadlock over political reform. Whether it's back-pedalling or the sort of "fighting retreat" former UK diplomat Tim Collard called for in a commentary last week, doesn't matter. What matters is that, even at the eleventh hour, a request for dialogue is better than just sitting around and waiting for political Armageddon.

Certainly there were opportunities to get the conversation going earlier, but there's no need to cry over spilled milk. If some hardliners are now willing to reconsider the merits of being moderate, then it should and must be deemed worth every effort in making it an actuality. At the very least, it would be a break from the maelstrom that has sucked the life out of practical politics.

A lot can happen in the next month.

Much is at stake here - for everyone, and not just for those poised to take to the streets the moment the National People's Congress Standing Committee ruling is handed down.

While we may have become accustomed to seeing events play out dramatically, and antagonistically, in the open, as they have in the last few months, we're going to have to have a lot of patience now. If there is to be any breakthrough, any possibility for a solution - theoretically or practically - must be entertained.

Based on the experience of electoral reform in the past, those who work behind the scenes, mainly through back-channel talks, hold the key to propelling us forward.

Within those hidden corridors of politics lies the hope that maybe, just maybe, a compromise can be reached, away from the floodlights of media and public scrutiny.

Of course, it would be ideal for all the negotiating to be done out in the open, but given the element of distrust that runs wide and deep in our social consciousness, that would be nearly impossible.

At the end of the day, though, we must believe that moderates from both sides can hammer out the best possible way forward. Otherwise, why would a moderate such as Ronny Tong Ka-wah, no stranger to the heat and the abuse of idealists who consistently reject practicality and reality, keep at it and invite more fury?

We must have faith that Tong and others like him believe that delivering results is worth infinitely more than high-strung uncompromising rhetoric.

We must also have faith that when the war of words is at its height, the door for "quiet" conversations often swings open. And it's not too late to call for and borrow from the spirit and strategies of quiet diplomacy.

That is the sort of political manoeuvring that has allowed the Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak, winning support even from the opposition, for brokering the deal that secured the release of MH17's flight recorders and brought home the remains of the victims.

As Razak said: "Sometimes, we must work quietly in the service of a better outcome."

For Hong Kong and Beijing, we're in the middle of one of those times now.

Alice Wu is a political consultant and a former associate director of the Asia Pacific Media Network at UCLA


Related topics

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

Ant Lee
Alice Wu is nothing other than one of those whose job is being a pro-communist mouth piece.
the sun also rises
Once the ruling of the Standing Committee of National People's Congress (of which local leftist union head, Cheng Yiu-tong was said would be present) is handed down, very soon, the long-awaited planned non-violent civil-obedience campaign, 'Occupy Central' will definitely break out at a certain place in Central ( not outside the Government headquarters of course since it is now being surrounded by high iron fence !) and roads might be blocked for days while thousands of protesters (including lots of students) might be arrested and duly charged with blocking the roads and unauthorized gathering plus obstruction of the exeution of due duties of the cops and organised illegal gathering as well. Maybe a few will be charged with causing troubles and provoking quarrels ---as their counterparts (the rights activitsts on Mainland China } received ! Just see how the movement will end up and whether the PLA garrison will be mobilized as they have been under vigorous anti-riots trainings in Shenzhen ever since early 2014 !
An ornate and poignant political commentary does any good to the grim situation facing Hong Kong. Every time this columnist preaches the same tenets of universal suffrage has to be on show and on time in 2017. Boring. All Hong Kong people aspire to see it happen but the controverisal point is how it is implemented. You pinpoints the importance of communication between the government and the pro-democracy groups but at the same invariably lays the blame of the current political impasse on the democratic who have long been making unfailing efforts to make genuine democracy possible.
The key to a fruitful communication is to listen. Government does not listen to the public and their representatives but to our distant "grandfather". No matter how angry you are with the democratic camp in Hong Kong through your barrage of criticisms against them, any concrete outcome could be made.
So Miss Wu, before you pen each time, please think about who you should blame.


SCMP.com Account