Advertisement
Opinion

The tragedy of suicide: good journalism can help

Paul Yip says simplistic, insensitive coverage affects the vulnerable

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Media reports on the teenager who jumped to her death should not engage in wild speculation about the circumstances that led to the death. Photo: Sam Tsang
Paul Yip

The recent apparent suicide of a teenage girl who didn't have a birth certificate occupied the front pages of many major local newspapers. Some of the coverage explored the complex issues around the case but much of it was insensitive and lurid. Sharing personal Facebook posts and speculating as to how they might explain suicidal actions, as one newspaper did, is not helpful. It encourages an oversimplified interpretation of events, and also shows a lack of consideration for distress caused to the victim's family and friends.

The episode shows that more needs to be done to encourage responsible journalism.

Much research has been done around the world which shows how media reporting on suicide can affect the behaviour of vulnerable individuals. Our own research reveals that insensitive reporting can contribute to an increase in suicides. Young people, who are prone to peer influence, are especially likely to be affected by public accounts of suicide, particularly if they have similar backgrounds.

Advertisement

To address this, some countries and regions have passed laws to protect children and adolescents' rights. For instance, Taiwan prohibits its press from reporting details of a child's or adolescent's suicide. Reporting on youth suicides is also rare in the West.

Besides legal regulations, the World Health Organisation and the International Association for Suicide Prevention have published guidelines for media reporting suicide, and similar guidelines have also been adopted in many countries. Our centre also introduced such guidelines to Hong Kong in 2004 and kept engaging local media professionals to report suicide news more responsibly.

Advertisement

The recommendations include not publishing photographs or suicide notes, not reporting specific details of the death, not giving simplistic reasons for suicide, not glorifying or sensationalising it, not using religious or cultural stereotypes, and not apportioning blame.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x