Advertisement
Opinion

The rich history of mistrust behind China’s warning to George Soros

Tom Plate says Beijing’s suspicion of Western financial advice has its roots in the Asian financial crisis

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
No Caption Available.
Tom Plate
Beijing’s warnings are directed generically rather than individually – at the global class of fast-buck investment jackals that care for no one’s welfare but their own.
Beijing’s warnings are directed generically rather than individually – at the global class of fast-buck investment jackals that care for no one’s welfare but their own.
There are more than a few financial figures in China circles who no longer trust Western financial advice (or most advisers) any more than they have to. There is a rich, as it were, history behind the mistrust. And in this, George Soros, no less, has a role. Here is the story.

We start our narrative with the Asian financial crisis of the late 1990s. For years, China had been relentlessly advised by US Treasury experts in the Bill Clinton administration, and by other prominent experts in the West, to stop babying its coddled currency and let it go outdoors onto the international markets to play fair and square with other big-time currencies.

US President Bill Clinton (right) gestures to Zhu Rongji during the premier’s visit to the US in 2008. For years, China had been advised by US Treasury experts in the Clinton administration to stop babying its coddled currency. Photo: AFP
US President Bill Clinton (right) gestures to Zhu Rongji during the premier’s visit to the US in 2008. For years, China had been advised by US Treasury experts in the Clinton administration to stop babying its coddled currency. Photo: AFP
For decades, this has been the constant whining pitch of the geek chorus in the West.
Advertisement

In fact, the argument has merit if China is to secure its place in the competitive world marketplace, of which central cosmopolitan idea Zhu Rongji (朱鎔基), the great former premier, was China’s world champion.

In fact, years later, Beijing itself moved in exactly that direction, in part to satisfy the International Monetary Fund that its currency would be cleanly convertible and so globally market-worthy.

Advertisement

But two decades ago, China was not ready for the big bad sandbox, felt both crowded and rushed by the West, and so held back.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x