Advertisement
Opinion
Zuraidah Ibrahim

Opinion | High time for a Hongkongers-first policy

Zuraidah Ibrahim says local officials wringing their hands over people’s discontent with ‘mainlandisation’ would do better to start addressing their grievances – first by meeting their practical needs in housing and jobs

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A supporter of localist activist Edward Leung holds up his picture at an election rally. Leung won over 15 per cent of the vote share. Photo: AP

Imagine seeing your city invaded by outsiders whose accent grates on you because it sounds so alien. After arriving at a certain quality of life, imagine suddenly facing neighbours who talk too loudly and think nothing of cutting queues.

Your child spends all her time on tuition and schoolwork, but is still beaten by a foreign kid who didn’t know a word of English when he arrived. And his parent seems to be beating you to the best jobs. You feel like a second-class citizen in your own city.

Hong Kong? No, that’s Singapore.

Advertisement

Such were the prevailing sentiments among Singaporeans in the late 2000s. The government, with its eyes on economic growth, had opened the doors widely to immigrants, mainly from China but also from South Asia and elsewhere. As a result, 40 per cent of the population came to be made up of non-citizens – one of the highest proportions in the world.

Immigration was the No 1 issue in the 2011 general election and the ruling party fared worse than in any other post-independence poll.

READ MORE: As Singapore prepares for election, immigration remains key issue

People practise tai chi in a park in Singapore. After a dismal showing at the general election in 2011, the ruling party began to adjust its immigration policies, and Singaporeans were assured in meaningful ways that they mattered more than the newcomers. Photo: Bloomberg
People practise tai chi in a park in Singapore. After a dismal showing at the general election in 2011, the ruling party began to adjust its immigration policies, and Singaporeans were assured in meaningful ways that they mattered more than the newcomers. Photo: Bloomberg
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x