Advertisement
My Take
Opinion
Alex Lo

My Take | Brouhaha over Putonghua is a recipe for failure

Localists must understand that to succeed in the world today, you must be able to speak and write the languages of business

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A man holds a sign professing his love for Cantonese, during a rally in Hong Kong to protest against the promotion of Putonghua. Photo: AFP
Alex Loin Toronto

My late father was a teenager when the Japanese occupied Hong Kong. By the end of the war, he and many of his friends were fluent in Japanese, having been forced to learn the language and sing the national anthem at school.

After the war, he made a conscious effort to unlearn Japanese, as he considered it the language of imperialism. By the time he qualified as a solicitor, he couldn’t speak the language anymore, though he still understood it when spoken to.

That was unfortunate as it was the 1960s, when the Japanese economy was taking off. Many Japanese companies such as car dealerships came to Hong Kong to set up shop, and they all needed legal services. There were clearly good business opportunities for my father. But he became self-conscious and easily embarrassed when he tried to speak Japanese.

Advertisement

The lesson he wanted to impart to his children was that learning a new language or dialect is never a bad thing, under whatever circumstances. And never let pride get it the way of learning new things.

It’s therefore sad that many young people today, especially those who are politically motivated, are increasingly rejecting Putonghua and simplified written Chinese scripts in the name of localism.

Advertisement

Since 1997, the government has actively promoted biliteracy and trilingualism – often referred to as mastering two languages (Chinese and English) and three ways of speaking (Cantonese, Putonghua and English).

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x