Advertisement
Legislative Council elections 2016
Opinion
Gary Cheung

Opinion | Move to sideline Hong Kong independence candidates is a misguided strategy

Gary Cheung says the rule requiring Legislative Council candidates to pledge their loyalty, by stating Hong Kong is an inalienable part of China, is overkill by anxious election officials

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A pro-independence protester holds up a flag that recalls British colonial days during the annual July 1 rally in the city. Photo: EPA
In an interview with me in March, Hong Kong and Macau Affairs Office deputy director Feng Wei (馮巍) said he was prepared to accept the reality of young radicals winning Legislative Council seats in the September election. I was surprised by the pragmatism of one of the top Beijing officials in charge of Hong Kong affairs.

Four months later, Hong Kong’s election officials have introduced a measure requiring candidates to sign a form declaring the city an inalienable part of China, on top of the standard declaration to uphold the Basic Law. The move may help turn Feng’s prediction to reality.

A few weeks before the Legco by-election for New Territories East in February, the Registration and Electoral Office refused to mail the politically sensitive election leaflets submitted by localist candidate Edward Leung Tin-kei. The office justified its stance by saying that words in the leaflets like “self-determination”, “self-rule” and “autonomy” are “fundamentally in breach of the Basic Law”, which states that Hong Kong is an inalienable part of China.

Advertisement
Edward Leung, a spokesman for Hong Kong Indigenous, a pro-independence localist group, stunned pundits and politicians alike by clinching 15.4 per cent of total valid votes cast in the New Territories East by-election . Photo: Bloomberg
Edward Leung, a spokesman for Hong Kong Indigenous, a pro-independence localist group, stunned pundits and politicians alike by clinching 15.4 per cent of total valid votes cast in the New Territories East by-election . Photo: Bloomberg

Onus is on government to explain why Legco candidates need to sign new ‘loyalty’ declaration

Ironically, the ban raised the public profile of Leung, an independence advocate. The University of Hong Kong student – a nobody before the Mong Kong riot on February 8 – stunned pundits and politicians alike by clinching 15.4 per cent of total valid votes cast in the by-election.

Advertisement

The new rule imposed by the election watchdog, which is on top of the standard declaration to uphold the Basic Law and pledge allegiance to the city, shows government officials have not learned the lesson from the refusal to mail Leung’s election material.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x