Advertisement

A blow to Hong Kong’s clean and fair electoral process – dealt by its own election officials

Cliff Buddle says the government’s apparent attempt to bar pro-independence candidates from standing in the Legco election is not only clumsy but may well be unlawful

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Cliff Buddle says the government’s apparent attempt to bar pro-independence candidates from standing in the Legco election is not only clumsy but may well be unlawful
The hasty, inconsistent and apparently arbitrary rejection of some candidates with little or no legal justification is ripe for challenge by judicial review. Illustration: Craig Stephens
The hasty, inconsistent and apparently arbitrary rejection of some candidates with little or no legal justification is ripe for challenge by judicial review. Illustration: Craig Stephens
Democratic reform remains a highly contentious issue in Hong Kong. But, for all the controversy over the city’s lack of universal and equal suffrage, we can take some pride in the Legislative Council elections.

The polls have become much more democratic over the years, despite the continued presence of small-circle functional constituencies. Most important of all, they are generally regarded as being clean and lawful, returning candidates from across the political spectrum.

But the integrity of next month’s election could now be undermined by the government’s clumsy intervention in the nominating process, in an apparent bid to exclude pro-independence candidates.

Advertisement

Prospective candidates were, for the first time, asked to sign an additional form when tendering their nomination.

Hong Kong’s electoral commission is losing credibility through inconsistent handling of localist candidates

The Legislative Council Ordinance already requires them to declare they will uphold the Basic Law and pledge allegiance to the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. That should be sufficient.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x