Advertisement
Narendra Modi
Opinion
Yonden Lhatoo

Just Saying | India’s leadership has got guts – if only Hong Kong could have some of it

Yonden Lhatoo sees bold and decisive leadership behind India’s controversial demonetisation drive, and can’t help contrasting it with Hong Kong’s situation

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Indian girls in Jammu wear masks depicting Narendra Modi and hold up new currency notes in support of the prime minister’s demonetisation drive to stamp out the use of black money. Photo: EPA

I still vividly remember the last time I was forced to pay a blatant bribe in India. It was quite a few years ago, at the cargo handling facility of New Delhi’s international airport, right under a big anti-bribery warning sign.

I was picking up a parcel that I had earlier arranged to be sent by cargo flight from Hong Kong when I realised I was being deliberately given the runaround, from counter to counter, unless I paid the ubiquitous “tea money”. So I did.

That was long before Narendra Modi became prime minister. I was in India again for a holiday last month, and returned to Hong Kong just a day before the shock and awe of his demonetisation drive. It was by chance that I missed the immediate panic it triggered.

Advertisement

In one fell swoop, on the evening of November 8, Modi declared all 500-rupee (HK$56) and 1,000-rupee notes invalid, effective from midnight. We’re talking about India’s two biggest currency denominations, accounting for 86 per cent of all the money in circulation. In a country where 90 per cent of the transactions use cash. You can imagine the impact. India is not quite ready to be a cashless society, with electronic payment still in its infancy.

Why Modi’s Indian banknote bombshell has shades of North Korea’s currency disaster

A trader counts money at Azadpur Mandi, one of Asia’s largest wholesale fruit and vegetable markets in New Delhi. The impact of the banknote ban cannot be overstated – 90 per cent of the transactions in India use cash. Photo: AP
A trader counts money at Azadpur Mandi, one of Asia’s largest wholesale fruit and vegetable markets in New Delhi. The impact of the banknote ban cannot be overstated – 90 per cent of the transactions in India use cash. Photo: AP
Modi’s move is a declaration of war against black money – only 2 to 3 per cent of some 1.3 billion Indians pay any income tax at all, which means ridiculously huge amounts of cash are hidden away and used under the table in a shadow economy that is estimated to account for up to 20 per cent of gross domestic product. All that dirty money can now be deposited in banks, but it’s taxable beyond a limited amount.
Advertisement

Whether he’s right or wrong to do it depends on who you’re talking to, three weeks after that apocalyptic announcement.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x