Hong Kong still needs a top-class concert hall. Maybe the Jockey Club can fund that, too?
Peter Kammerer says since the government appears unwilling to foot the bill for such a venue, despite Hong Kong’s great need for one, it’s time to explore other options
A city that rates itself as highly as Hong Kong should have cultural, entertainment and sporting facilities to match. One that is as cash-rich as ours has no excuse for not providing world-class venues for its people. Yet here we are, decades of such discussion having passed, and still we have facilities that are second- or even third-rate. Attend an event at our premier auditorium, the concert hall at the Cultural Centre on the Tsim Sha Tsui waterfront, and you’ll hear what I mean: inside a building that some refer to as looking like a large toilet block, the acoustics are appalling.
Beats of burden: Why Hong Kong’s music scene is suffering
Watch: The new stage of the Mariinsky Theatre
Watch: An introduction to the West Kowloon Cultural District
Hong Kong musicians lament loss of mega performance venue at site of Palace Museum
Hong Kong has a handful of smaller venues that have good reputations for acoustics, but none have more than a few hundred seats. Top-class artists would have to charge astronomical prices for tickets if they played public shows in such places. That leaves the cavernous Asia World Expo and the Exhibition Centre in Wan Chai, the big-crowd experience of the Coliseum and the Queen Elizabeth Stadium and the outdated and imperfect City Hall and Sha Tin and Tsuen Wan town halls. And, of course, there’s the much-maligned Cultural Centre. A complaint sometimes heard among show organisers is that our city lacks a venue that can seat between 2,000 and 10,000 people.
Venue problems have not kept international acts from our shores. A decade ago, Hong Kong was a cultural desert with our city being regularly bypassed by big names on their Asian and world tours, but no more; digital piracy has put an end to recording sales and artists are now forced to go on the road to earn a living. Classical artists are regular visitors and in the Western pop realm, acts over the past year have included Madonna, Morrissey and the Chemical Brothers and in coming weeks and months, there’ll be Metallica, James Taylor, Tom Jones, Journey, Madness, and From The Jam. But most are musically over the hill rather than at the top or in fashion, while the global top-grossing performers of the past year gave Hong Kong a wide berth.
10 Hong Kong events and shows in 2017 to look forward to
The Cultural Centre, built in 1989, has irregularly shaped internal walls that reflect and distort sound, giving a far-from-perfect experience for all but a small number of people in the audience. Musicians on stage have difficulty hearing themselves and one another. Keep in mind that this was a purpose-built venue; it’s unbelievable that acoustics remain so poor despite repeated efforts by the government to fix the problem. It gives an insight into why concerts elsewhere are so hit-and-miss when it comes to quality of experience. At the end of the day, it’s all about money.
Clearly, though, the Jockey Club isn’t short of cash and public charity. So here’s a suggestion: the Cultural Centre is an architectural, performance and experience mess. It also happens to occupy a harbourside site that would be perfect for an iconic building at which we can be wooed by the world’s finest performers. Tear it down, and if the government is too shy about spending what it is so greedily hoarding, have the club pay for a new concert complex using the latest technology to create a building that will do our city proud.
Peter Kammerer is a senior writer at the Post