Advertisement
Donald Trump
Opinion

Donald Trump’s moves on North Korea and China defy convention, but who says they can’t be right?

Tom Plate says not all of Trump’s unconventional conduct in foreign policy is deserving of condemnation, as most of the US media seems to believe

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Tom Plate says not all of Trump’s unconventional conduct in foreign policy is deserving of condemnation, as most of the US media seems to believe
Tom Plate
Maybe if Donald Trump’s clock were ticking normally, he’d never get anything right. Who knows? Illustration: Craig Stephens
Maybe if Donald Trump’s clock were ticking normally, he’d never get anything right. Who knows? Illustration: Craig Stephens
There is a funny but technically accurate saying to the effect that even a broken clock is right twice a day. This adage comes to mind in looking at Donald Trump’s emerging foreign policy.
Consider the US president’s efforts to engage with Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) and with North Korean leader Kim Jong-un. They are not unfolding according to normal practice. So protocol purists are in a dither. International theorists are in high dudgeon. The anti-Trump US media (which is most of it) is heaping scorn.

In the case of Xi and China, the complaint is not over a paucity of communication between the two leaders but a plethora. Some reporters joke that Trump phones Xi almost as often as first lady Melania. Ordinarily, personal diplomacy is applauded but, collectively, our media commentariat and talk-show hosts are so negative on Trump, that if famous cold war strategist George Kennan rose from the dead and offered a good word for the new president on personal engagement, the media would probably paint this as a Russian trick or the like.

Advertisement

One US media story suggested, with thin sourcing, that Xi was feeling “pestered” by Trump’s near-constant phoning and hardly knows what to do with his new, clueless pal. But is this credible? China’s hard-working president is obviously no slacker but he’d have to be just that to feel “pestered” by calls from the president of the US. On the contrary, it’s a feather in Xi’s Mao cap. It’s not as if he’s being “pestered” by some minister from the Maldives. In China-US relations, continuing communication is vital. Less is not more.

Xi Jinping and Donald Trump still need to find a strategic footing

Perhaps the fraught issue of the Korean peninsula “crisis” accounts in part for the hotline upsurge. Trump, clearly agitated by the Pyongyang bee in his bonnet, has declaimed that the “crisis” will be solved by the US alone, if Beijing decides not to pitch in. Nobody anywhere seems to know what this might mean. But it cannot be good: for starters, a US Navy carrier group is bobbing near the Korean peninsula; the head of the CIA recently visited Seoul; and a THAAD anti-missile system is now operational in South Korea. The fact is that most South Koreans don’t want the thing and the Chinese hate the thing – it’s an obnoxiously offensive intrusion into their neighbourhood. Trump doesn’t seem to care.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x