Advertisement
Just Saying
Opinion
Yonden Lhatoo

Just Saying | Are Hong Kong’s pan-democrats finished? ‘Staplegate’ is a sign of the times

Yonden Lhatoo bemoans the downfall of the city’s opposition camp, spotlighting its highly questionable handling of Howard Lam’s kidnap and torture claims

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Howard Lam holds up a Lionel Messi postcard at a press conference in Hong Kong, as former Democratic Party chief Martin Lee Chu-ming looks on, on August 11. Lam claimed he was tortured as he planned to give the signed postcard from the Barcelona football star to Liu Xia, the widow of Liu Xiaobo. Photo: EPA/Handout

“Politics is the art of looking for trouble, finding it whether it exists or not, diagnosing it incorrectly, and applying the wrong remedy,” a wise man once wrote.

Is that the story of Hong Kong’s pan-democrats?

There used to be a time when they were seen as a meaningful opposition force to counter some of the shoeshiners, sycophants and rubber stampers in the pro-establishment camp that has always dominated the city’s legislature. Not any more.

Advertisement

Not only are they becoming more irrelevant and ineffectual by the day, they seem to be plumbing new depths of political farce and buffoonery. Just look at the circus that has been dubbed “Staplegate”.

I’m talking about the way they handled the case of Democratic Party member Howard Lam Tsz-kin, who shocked the city with his sensational story about being kidnapped and tortured by mainland agents operating outside their jurisdiction.
[The Lam case] has left the pan-democrats with egg on their faces and their credibility in tatters

Lam claimed he was snatched by Putonghua-speaking men from a busy street in broad daylight, bundled into a van and taken to an unknown location where they punched staples into his legs before dumping him on a beach last week.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x