-
Advertisement
Carrie Lam
Opinion

How ‘one country, two systems’ is tearing Beijing and Hong Kong further apart

Michael Chugani says cross-party fraternity in Hong Kong politics, as sought by Carrie Lam, is a fantasy, as it would be political suicide for the opposition to cosy up to the establishment in such a polarised society

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam and her predecessor, Leung Chun-ying, at the World Chinese Economic Summit, in Admiralty on November 13. Photo: David Wong
Michael Chugani
Remember the fanciful talk just four months ago? We can finally have a grand reconciliation after five dark years of the loathed Leung Chun-ying as chief executive. No more hate talk, political knives and gridlock. Opposition and establishment forces would together heal our split society. That was top of then incoming Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor’s wish list.

I knew at the time only those living in never-never land would believe in such fantasy. Reconciliation will never happen because Lam’s wish would be a death wish for the opposition. That’s why even her charm offensive didn’t win her a political honeymoon.

Don’t be lulled into thinking last week’s overtures by some opposition legislators signalled an end to acrimony with the establishment.

They are the opposition and will remain so in perpetuity

To understand why it’s political suicide for the opposition to cosy up to the establishment, we must first accurately define its members. We have inaccurately labelled them as pan-democrats or pro-democracy. They are the opposition and will remain so in perpetuity under our executive-led government.

Advertisement

When the constitution doesn’t allow you a crack at governing, the only path to votes in a highly polarised society is to oppose.

Our first post-handover chief executive, Tung Chee-hwa, found that out the hard way.

Advertisement

A businessman turned political leader who foolishly believed Hongkongers would patriotically unite upon freedom from the chains of colonial rule, he was driven from office when half a million took to the streets.

Protesters carrying banners reading “Fight For Democratic Elections in 2007 and 2008”, and inflatable dolls depicting then Hong Kong chief executive Tung Chee-hwa, march to the central government’s liaison office to protest against Beijing’s interpretation of the Basic Law, in April 2004. Photo: SCMP Pictures
Protesters carrying banners reading “Fight For Democratic Elections in 2007 and 2008”, and inflatable dolls depicting then Hong Kong chief executive Tung Chee-hwa, march to the central government’s liaison office to protest against Beijing’s interpretation of the Basic Law, in April 2004. Photo: SCMP Pictures
Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x