Advertisement
My Take | Yes to free speech, no to free-for-all on university campuses
William Kirby, a professor at Harvard, says universities in Hong Kong should allow open debate on all issues including independence, yet his own institution, among others in the US and Britain, sees fit to disinvite speakers
Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Alex Loin Toronto
Such lofty sentiment! William Kirby, a professor at Harvard and an adviser to the University of Hong Kong on governance, has been quoted as saying that on university campuses, any subject should be up for discussion. That was the case at Harvard, he said, as long as it was conducted within the boundaries of propriety.
The good professor must have been speaking in a moment of moral exuberance. I am sure it isn’t the case with Harvard. It is not the case with most American universities.
Advertisement
“At a place like Harvard, anyone can invite anybody to give a speech … it’s a mistake to keep people from speaking,” he said. “A great university must be a place where there is not even one question, let alone seven, that cannot be discussed.”
In September, Harvard’s famous John F. Kennedy School of Government, the alma mater of many of our top civil servants, including former chief executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen, disinvited Chelsea Manning as a visiting fellow following complaints from CIA Director Mike Pompeo, former CIA deputy director Michael Morell and ex-Trump White House spokesman Sean Spicer, among others.
Advertisement
Manning was the army intelligence analyst who leaked classified information, through WikiLeaks, exposing the wanton killings of civilians, including journalists, in Iraq and Afghanistan by the US military. She served seven years in jail.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x