Advertisement
Macroscope
Opinion
Neal Kimberley

Macroscope | Trump’s tweet-worthy jobs data should be tempered with attention to other indicators

Neal Kimberley says even encouraging signs from US non-farm payrolls and average hourly earnings data should not be viewed in isolation. Rather, retail sales figures and the flat Treasury yield curve tell a less optimistic story

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
US job seekers in Fall River, Massachusetts, line up during Amazon Jobs Day, an event that aimed to fill more than 50,000 jobs on August 2, 2017. Last week, claims for state unemployment benefits fell to their lowest level since 1973. Photo: Reuters
“JOBS, JOBS, JOBS! Unemployment claims have fallen to a 45-year low,” tweeted US President Donald Trump last week. The risk, though, is that the data flatters to deceive.

This Friday’s US non-farm payrolls figure and average hourly earnings income data are the main focus for markets, and both sets of numbers shouldn’t be viewed in isolation.

That aside, it’s only fair to Trump to note that initial claims for state unemployment benefits, for the week that ended March 24, did fall by 12,000 to a seasonally adjusted 215,000, and that was the lowest level seen since January 1973. From Trump’s perspective, it was a tweet-worthy moment. 

Advertisement
While a figure below 300,000 for US weekly jobless claims is often seen as signifying a strong labour market, it’s also worth noting the number marked 158 straight weeks beneath that level, stretching back well into president Barack Obama’s second term, a fact which, perhaps understandably, didn’t make it into Trump’s tweet.
It might well be that while the US economy has been creating lots of jobs, those jobs are not particularly well paid

Yet it’s that 158-week run which is arguably more important than the 45-year low, because the length of time the US jobs market has been strong hasn’t really translated, at least so far, into marked accelerations in average hourly earnings. In 2017, average hourly earnings grew by 2.5 per cent over the year, amounting to a rise of just 65 cents, to December’s figure of US$26.63. 

Advertisement

Of course, it might well be that while the US economy has been creating lots of jobs, those jobs are not particularly well paid. Perhaps that helps explain why, even though the US jobs market is robust, US retail sales fell in February for the third month in succession.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x