• Fri
  • Dec 19, 2014
  • Updated: 8:32am
Occupy Central

Lack of political tolerance

PUBLISHED : Monday, 08 April, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Monday, 08 April, 2013, 2:04am

The Focus article by Joshua But and Gary Cheung ("Academic's road map to democracy", March 28) raised a question that has been asked in Hong Kong since the early 1960s, when Britain ruled this former colony, depriving people of the right to vote for legislative councillors.

There was a time when injustices were rife, corruption a way of life, and wealth accumulated for the favoured few who were appointees to the legislative and executive councils, and who were mostly British. "Democracy" then was a dirty word to the British colonials.

Those who dared to propose electing members were dubbed "pink".

One kind-hearted person was Bishop Ronald Hall, who tried to help the poor and provide education for them. He was dubbed the "pink" bishop.

Some of our governors (Murray MacLehose, Edward Youde and David Wilson) were at heart democratic, but it was only the last governor, Chris Patten, who seems to have been authorised to make a show of democracy by collaborating with a few new "democrats" who had crept out of the woodwork to damage the hopes of a smooth through-train in 1997.

I do not know Dr Benny Tai Yiu-ting, but I wonder how long he has lived in Hong Kong, and whether Deliberation Day, the book that inspired him, written by two American political scientists, proposes a U-turn in Hong Kong's liberation from colonialism in 1997. Perhaps Dr Tai can explain his liking for the book.

I consider myself democratic, allowing everyone to have his own political views. But some of our Johnny-come-lately democrats permit no views but their own.

The march of 500,000 people a few years ago was hailed by lawmaker Emily Lau Wai-hing as a march for democracy.

In the press she had called for all people with a complaint about anything to join the march. Many people with various complaints did march, but the next day Miss Lau said 500,000 had marched for democracy. Among them were Filipinos and Indonesians, who already have universal suffrage, but at election times are told to sell their votes, and threatened if they fail to do so. In every election in those countries there is violence. So much for universal suffrage. Many would prefer to live in "undemocratic" Hong Kong.

Perhaps Dr Tai would like to visit and see the corrupt democracies through foreign "friendship". The fact is that some of the post-1997 so-called democrats in Hong Kong are actually delaying our democratic progress by their undemocratic actions.

Elsie Tu, Kwun Tong


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

It's just absurd to try and score points off different political systems through reference to failed democracies. For every great democracy there are places like Indonesia and for every successful one party state there are places like N Korea.
Neither agree nor disagree with the thesis, but your arguments are weak and too one sided. D -. Can improve.
Elsie Tu is my patron saint of Hong Kong. She is far too kind to condemn some people for they really are: self-hate Chinese scumbags.
hard times !
Elsie Tu was highly respected in the sixties and seventies of last century by many ethic Chinese here in the territory for her courage and justice-seeking attitude against the corrupted Colonial government.When I was then a junior clerk in the government,once I learnt that some nasty guys were going to kill her in a car 'accident' for her just acts done for the underpriveleged. Yet after the Handover in 1997, she has changed herself completely by siding with the new master: the Communist-appointed SAR administration.What a pity ! Elsie claims that she herself is a democrat.Maybe it was true several decades ago but definitely not now ! Democrats are democrats and autocratic government is autocratic government.By far,the best political system in the whole world is still democracy which allows people to choose their government by votes or veto it by votes again.
So, Elsie, according to what you now do, we should all follow suit and heap praise, support and legitimize the Communist Party government which allows no marches at all let alone 500,000.
Elsie, you have always done Hong Kong a disservice by your turncoat ways, or perhaps you prefer one party rule to the people voting for a person who might stand up for HK people only to be quickly dismissed through means that a one party totalitarian state commands.
Whatever way it cuts, Elsie, you are no Bolshevie, merely a tired old woman who needs to put aside whatever misdeed or perceived injustice the last colonial government (Fatty Pang included) inflicted on and enjoy what's left of your dotage.
P.S. I am Chinese, born in Sha Tau Kok and have seen too many like you.


SCMP.com Account