• Sat
  • Dec 27, 2014
  • Updated: 9:37pm
CommentLetters

Opening another zoo will send wrong message to children

PUBLISHED : Monday, 05 May, 2014, 3:01am
UPDATED : Monday, 05 May, 2014, 3:01am

I oppose the suggestion that there is a need for another zoo in Hong Kong ("Animal instinct? Kids want 'real zoo'", April 22).

For generations we have wilfully destroyed natural habitats and caused a global species crisis. In an attempt to rectify this appalling situation, we convince ourselves it is okay to keep wild animals in captivity so that we can "educate" people about the threats to their survival, with the belief that displaying animals in unnatural environments and, in a number of cases, training them to perform for our entertainment, will help to reverse this downward spiral.

This approach needs a fundamental shift if we are to prevent the further destruction of habitats and loss of species we are currently experiencing. Children must learn about nature and the need to protect it by experiencing nature for themselves, and this experience must be within the natural environment and not within the confines of a concrete and wire enclosure.

Hong Kong is home to almost 3,000 varieties of flowering plants, and more than 2,000 moth, 110 dragonfly and 230 butterfly species. It is home to many native birds, reptiles, amphibians and mammals.

This includes two resident cetaceans, the Chinese white dolphin and the finless porpoise.

As educators we should foster empathy and respect for this rich array of native wildlife, and use this empathy and respect as a springboard for our children to learn about other non-native species.

We must ensure our children are aware of their presence and the threats they face. Our children can then think about the choices they can make to help to protect and conserve these species within their natural environment.

Having another zoo in Hong Kong would create the opposite scenario, teaching children that it is acceptable to keep animals outside their natural habitats, and for us to manage individual animals' lives so that we are able to view them for our own pleasure and entertainment.

Animals Asia Foundation is opposed to the development of another zoo in Hong Kong. It urges the government to ensure that all schoolchildren have access to humane education opportunities that develop a connection with the native wildlife of Hong Kong, ensuring that the next generation can find the necessary solutions to the current national and international biodiversity crisis which has been created by this one.

David Neale, animal welfare director, Animals Asia Foundation

Share

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive
 
 

 

 
 
 
 
 

This article is now closed to comments

DinGao
What we should be doing is relocating the orangutans to a dedicated sanctuary like the island of Yeung Chau in Sai Kung (still an unused agricultural lease which will get turned into a playboy's paradise before long.)
You only have to visit Singapore Zoo's wonderful orangutan facility to realise how awful HK's orangutans living conditions really are.
Still, I suppose that as long as HK tolerates caged living for its elderly poor, our orangutans will have to suffer too.

Login

SCMP.com Account

or