Samsung’s new personal digital assistant Bixby faces a few tough challenges
The battle for domination of the digital assistant market has intensified with Samsung’s voice-operated Bixby joining taking on Siri, Alexa and Cortana
Samsung’s Bixby is the new kid on the block of personal digital assistants and is likely to face a rough reception in a neighbourhood dominated by tech sector rivals.
Bixby – introduced at Samsung’s unveiling of Galaxy S8 smartphones in New York last month - aims to help the South Korean giant break into a surging market for voice-activated virtual assistants, which includes Apple’s Siri, Amazon’s Alexa, Google’s Assistant and Microsoft’s Cortana.
The latest personal digital assistant distinguishes itself from competitors by using voice commands to control handsets or applications, factoring in location awareness and image recognition.
The integrated camera function allows users to identify buildings, such as popular tourist sites, to access their websites and other information simply by snapping a photo.
The photo recognition technology can also help users decipher menus in foreign languages, or find places to shop for specific items they photograph.
“It impressed me that they were doing image recognition and context awareness,” says Bob O’Donnell, analyst and consultant with Technalysis Research, who attended the presentation.
“It adds some new twists we haven’t seen before,” he says, noting Bixby’s ability to make recommendations.
Yet Bixby is still a work in progress – the virtual entity did not speak at the New York demonstration. It has yet to be infused with technology from Samsung’s recently acquired Viv, a company founded by creators of Apple’s Siri.
“It’s not talking yet,” O’Donnell says. “They have room to expand and grow.”
Bixby will face competition from established players.
Richard Windsor, an independent analyst who writes the Radio Free Mobile blog, says Bixby may face problems because the “best-in-class Google Assistant” will be on the home button of the new phone, which is powered by Google-backed Android software.
That means Bixby has a “fearsome competitor” on its own flagship device, according to the analyst.
“Bixby is trying to do things a little differently, but careful assessment of what Samsung demonstrated shows a service that has very little intelligence at all,” Windsor says.
Roger Kay of Endpoint Technologies Associates says Bixby might face challenges catching up with its rivals, which have been deployed for some time.
“You can’t build these things overnight,” Kay says. “It would take years to create something as developed as Siri.”
Still, he notes, it is important for Samsung to be in the game. “You can’t not deal with voice. It’s hands-free and can summarise a lot of things quickly.”
Amazon appears to have affected the sector the most with its connected speakers using Alexa. The service allows users a wide range of voice interactions for music, news, purchases and connects with smart home devices.
“Alexa is the top dog,” Kay says. “Amazon has done the best work from a commercial perspective. They took it out of the theoretical to put it to work for things people want to do.”
Samsung has also promoted Bixby as a remote hub for connected devices, which is another challenge as it takes the software beyond the smartphone.
Patrick Moorhead, analyst with Moor Insights & Strategy, says Bixby’s success in the connected home may depend on how much data it can collect.
“Machine learning gets better the more training it gets and the more data it gets,” Moorhead says.
While Bixby cannot benefit from the large databases of competitors Apple and Windows, it could potentially sync with Samsung electronics and smart home appliances through Samsung’s SmartThings platform.
“Samsung ships so many devices, from phones to Chromebooks to washing machines, it is picking up a different set of information, so it might end up being smarter than Siri,” he says. “Siri doesn’t know what’s in your refrigerator, Samsung does.”
The app faces an uphill battle in a fragmented market where competing platforms don’t always work together.
Moorhead says tech companies are jockeying for a position in order to “get access to data – by using this interface they can build detailed profiles on you.”