If there are no atheists in foxholes, there aren't many at a Bach concert either, at least while the music is playing. This oratorio performance had such conviction it transcended its Lutheran setting and spoke to the universal experience of loss and betrayal.

The choir began with a lilting passage underpinned with profound pedal tones. The first rising phrase of the choir hinted at the power to come. Hailing from London, the Bach choir featured both beautiful tone and diction. All the contrapuntal sections were clear, the words convincing. The Chamber Boys of the Hong Kong Children's Choir also held their own, with their chorale melodies soaring.

The audience was rapt during dramatic spots, most notably when Jesus called out, "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?"

Stephan Ruegamer was a superb Evangelist, singing his narration with a high note that rang through the hall. The rest of the singers, with their intense expressions, sang as if they meant every word. One of many electric moments came during Ruegamer's fadeout as Christ died on the cross.