-
Advertisement
PostMag
Life.Culture.Discovery.
Old Hong Kong
MagazinesPostMag
Jason Wordie

Then & Now | Why Hong Kong independence movement is dead in the water

Long before handover negotiations began, those in the know understood China would never tolerate any separate state on its turf

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A member of "We are Hongkongers, Not Chinese" waves the colonial Hong Kong flag outside the central government's liason office in Western district on October 1, 2012. Picture: Dickson Lee

Renowned British political philosopher Isaiah Berlin noted in 1958, in the essay “Two Concepts of Liberty”, that “concepts nurtured in the stillness of a professor’s study could destroy a civilisation”. History demonstrates that we underestimate the transformative power of seemingly wacky ideas – and the individuals who promulgate them – at our peril.

For instance, Adolf Hitler’s autobiographical Mein Kampf was routinely dismissed as far-out ravings when first published, in two volumes, in 1925 and 1927. Yet within a decade, its chillingly coherent message had brought Europe to the brink of destruction.
Advertisement

Anna Wu (left), who led a delegation of the Hong Kong Observers to Beijing for a week-long visit, is surrounded by reporters on arrival at Kai Tak Airport, in December 1983. Picture: SCMP
Anna Wu (left), who led a delegation of the Hong Kong Observers to Beijing for a week-long visit, is surrounded by reporters on arrival at Kai Tak Airport, in December 1983. Picture: SCMP
Advertisement

All it takes for evil to flourish – the old truism proclaims – is for the good to do nothing. And so it is with nonsense in academic life. Once superficially plausible drivel breaks the species barrier and crosses over from university seminar room to infect the general public, dangerous contagion begins. Interested parties – and Hong Kong has no shortage of those, right across the political spectrum – help feed the contami­nation, which begins its hard-to-stop advance into wider society.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x