• Thu
  • Dec 18, 2014
  • Updated: 10:27pm

Jakarta tells Singapore to stop 'acting like a child' over forest fire smog

Jakarta tells Singapore to stop complaining about forest-fire smog as it's due to nature

PUBLISHED : Friday, 21 June, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Friday, 21 June, 2013, 10:56am

Indonesia yesterday accused Singapore of acting "like a child" over choking smog from forest fires in Sumatra that has triggered the city-state's worst environmental crisis in more than a decade.

The escalation in tensions between tiny Singapore and its vast neighbour came as haze levels enveloping the island hit a record high, shrouding the whole city.

As the acrid smell crept into flats and medical masks sold out, Singapore Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said the crisis could last weeks and urged people to pull together.

The city-state ratcheted up pressure on Jakarta to take "definitive action" to extinguish the fires - but Indonesia, which insists that Singapore-owned plantations on Sumatra also share the blame, hit back.

"Singapore should not be behaving like a child and making all this noise," Agung Laksono, the minister co-ordinating Indonesia's response, said. "This is not what the Indonesian nation wants, it is because of nature."

His comments came as Indonesia's foreign ministry hosted an emergency meeting in Jakarta attended by Singapore's National Environment Agency chief executive Andrew Tan.

Singapore's air pollution index hit an all-time high yesterday, soaring to 371 at 1pm, well past the previous record of 321 set the night before. Any reading above 300 is "hazardous" while a reading above 400 is deemed "life-threatening to ill and elderly people," government guidelines say.

Lee declined to respond to Laksono's comments, saying he did not want to engage in "megaphone diplomacy".

He urged people to stay indoors and protect themselves from the haze which has hung over the island since Monday, asking citizens to "look out for one another". "We cannot tell how the haze problem will develop," Lee said. "It can easily last for several weeks and quite possibly longer until the dry season ends in Sumatra."

CBD pharmacies sold out of disposable masks and refused to take orders, as the strong odour seeped into homes.

Parks were empty of the usual morning joggers, but thousands of employees still trooped to offices and labourers continued to work on high-rise buildings.

"This is now the worst haze that Singapore has ever faced," Environment Minister Vivian Balakrishnan said on Facebook. "We need urgent and definitive action by Indonesia to tackle the problem at source. Singaporeans have lost patience, and are understandably angry, distressed and concerned."

Parts of Malaysia close to Singapore have also been affected.

Laksono said plans to use cloud-seeding to unleash rain over Sumatra were under way, and it was hoped helicopters could be dispatched today.

Smallholders and plantations in Sumatra - some of them with Singaporean investors - have been accused of using fire to clear land for cultivation .


More on this story

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

Corrupted Indonesian officials are lying through their teeth by calling the fires are caused by nature. It's an annual affair since 1997, the man made fires to clear the forest for palm oil plantations.
When you have morons such as this Agung Laksono as ministers, how do you expect to ever prosper and become great??? Indonesia is such a big country blessed with many resources but is so much poorer than a small little Singapore with practically no resources......ever wonder why?? The quality and caliber of the people in the government. Add corruptions to it and there you are........the different between Singapore and Indonesia. Here in the story above is a classic example of moron vs talent (a.k.a Agung vs Lee).
I guess now whenever people complain and say Singapore has better air quality than HK, we can point to this and say that they are wrong..
Its extremely terrible in Singapore. I am not sure how much longer we can cope with this in Singapore:
Some Singaporeans are calling for military intervention:
Military intervention for what ? you'll fly your air force inside Indonesia and what will Indonesia do ? they will just burn more forest and put sulphur so all you'll inhale in Singapore is Sulphur all your soldiers will get sick and citizens ... without even moving their Indonsian military Singapore would lose. Singaporean always think their money, advance weapon and being brat would help them ... sad to say not all things you can buy with money, most especially when you are fighting with the nature itself .. Indonesia is doing their best resolving this issue but sometimes karma karma karma can't be prevented... learn how to pray.
Won't You Be My Neighbour (with apologies to Mister Rogers)
It's a beautiful day in this neighborhood,
A beautiful day for a neighbor.
Would you be mine?
Could you be mine?...
It's a neighborly day in this beauty wood,
A neighborly day for a beauty.
Would you be mine?
Could you be mine?...
I've always wanted to have a neighbor just like you.
I've always wanted to live in a neighborhood with you.
So, let's make the most of this beautiful day.
Since we're together we might as well say:
Would you be mine?
Could you be mine?
Won't you be my neighbor?
Won't you please,
Won't you please?
Please won't you be my neighbor?
Indonesia accuses Singapore of childish response!
It is Indonesia that is the child.
Singapore has good airforce.What is it for?
So far as we know just now, nothing is ruled in and nothing is ruled out.
tfung. I'm sorry. But it won't work. HK's air pollution is toxic period. Throughout the year. The haze in Singapore happens only during brief periods every year. This year is especially bad. But it's a one-off.
I heard it differently from an old colleague years ago that seems burning the forest to make space for palm plantation is a yearly practice. The only difference is the magnitude. While for Hong Kong, be fair, the quality is improving though the speed might still be far from satisfactory. Besides our own internal pollution sources such as power generation plant, vehicle, factories, construction sites and vessels, external sources like factories and power stations condition in Guangdong province are being monitored and rectified. It's a work in progress with neighbor under the same roof of the same country. For Singapore, their counterpart is a foreign country to them and who can be sure that things would be definitely developing towards a direction or result which Singapore would be satisfied or happy about?
Sorry, but I must disagree. S'pore has MUCH BETTER air quality than HK. This poor air is a one off in S'pore, while the recent clean air in HK is a one off from toxic air pollution



SCMP.com Account